Oscillation Maintains Polymorphisms — a Model of Lateral Asymmetry in Two Competing Scale-eating Cichlids

doi:10.1006/jtbi.1998.0744

Journal of Theoretical Biology

Volume 195, Issue 1, 7 November 1998, Pages 1-12

https://doi.org/10.1006/jtbi.1998.0744 Get rights and content

Abstract

Scale-eating cichlids in Lake Tanganyika exhibit lateral asymmetry polymorphism in their mouth-opening. Frequency of left- and right-handed phenotypes oscillates around unity. In the southern shore of the lake, two scale-eaters coexist in similar densities, where their oscillation synchronize. This phenomena is analysed by a time delay differential equation model, and new mechanisms which maintains polymorphism is discovered. In a wide range of parameters, the oscillation keeps the frequencies of the same phenotype in the two species at a similar level, and prevents the fixation of one phenotype in either species.

References (0)

Cited by (16)

Coexistence of competing species by the oscillation of polymorphisms
2005, Journal of Theoretical Biology
Scale-eating cichlids in Lake Tanganyika exhibit genetically determined lateral asymmetry, especially in their mouth-opening. Frequencies of the morphs oscillate due to strong frequency-dependent selection caused by the switching of prey's attention, and its delayed effect by their growth period. Two scale-eaters coexist in similar densities at south shore of the lake, with their morph frequencies oscillating in phase. We investigated the effect of the oscillation in morph frequencies to the coexistence of competing species. If the difference of two species’ growth period is large, the oscillation facilitates the coexistence of the two species, while small difference of growth periods hinders their coexistence. In the latter case, the species with shorter growth period drives the other species to the extinction.
Adaptive, pre-adaptive and non-adaptive components of radiations in ancient lakes: A review
2004, Organisms Diversity and Evolution
Ancient lakes are ideal model systems for evolutionary studies, as they hold hundreds of endemic species. The vast majority of these still occur in the cradle of their origin. We distinguish three different modes of speciation (allo-, para- and sympatric) which have occurred in these habitats. Although radiations from ancient lakes are generally assumed to be adaptive, we cannot fully support this point of view, because non-adaptive radiations also appear to be common, for example through chromosomal changes, hybridization or sexual selection. Even in supposedly adaptive cladogenesis, e.g. as concerns the presumed trophic adaptations of cichlid (Pisces) mouth and tooth shapes, both adaptive and non-adaptive components are acting. Distribution patterns of non-marine ostracods (Crustacea) within and outside of ancient lakes indicate that sexual reproduction might be an additional requirement for successful radiations in ancient lakes, at least in certain groups. This can best be understood by invoking ecology-based hypotheses on the evolutionary superiority of sexual reproduction such as Fisher–Muller accelerated evolution and the Tangled Bank.
Spatial pattern formation in a model ecosystem: Exchange between symbiosis and competition
2001, Physics Letters, Section A: General, Atomic and Solid State Physics
Dynamics of Laterality in the Cuttlefish Sepia recurvirostra through Interactions with Prey Prawns
2022, Zoological Science
Dynamics of Laterality in Relation to the Predator-Prey Interaction between the Piscivorous Chub "hasu" and Its Prey "ayu" in Lake Biwa
2021, Zoological Science
Dynamics of laterality in Lake Tanganyika scale-eaters driven by Cross-Predation
2019, Symmetry

View all citing articles on Scopus

View full text

Regular articleOscillation Maintains Polymorphisms — a Model of Lateral Asymmetry in Two Competing Scale-eating Cichlids

Abstract

Regular article
Oscillation Maintains Polymorphisms — a Model of Lateral Asymmetry in Two Competing Scale-eating Cichlids