Abstract
Introduction
Knot tying is regarded as a basic surgical skill. However, there is no consensus in the literature on the best/safest technique. The aim of this study was to survey the various techniques used by German surgeons at the different stages of their training.
Materials and methods
A knot tying technique was defined based on three criteria, i.e., both thread ends are crossed at the beginning at least two throws tied pulling at the same free end of the thread (standing part) and at least one knot tied changing the standing part. The knot tying techniques of 192 randomly chosen German surgeons practicing in 102 different hospitals were compared against this standard. Besides the status of the participating surgeons, the type of hospital in which they were currently working was recorded.
Results
Of the192 participants, 69 were consultants, 56 fellows, and 67 residents. Forty-three surgeons (22.4%) worked in primary care centers (PCC), 81 (42.2%) in secondary care centers (SCC), and 68 (35.4%) in tertiary care centers (TCC). 62.5% crossed both thread ends at the beginning, 75.5% performed at least two identical throws keeping the same standing part, and 45.3% changed the standing part. Assessed against the technique defined as standard, 19.8% of all surgeons performed similar surgical knots. Even though consultants crossed both thread ends at the beginning and changed the standing part significantly more often (p = 0.007 and p = 0.031 respectively, Fisher’s exact test), the overall rate of identical knots was independent of the status of participants and the type of hospital (p > 0.1, Fisher’s exact test).
Conclusion
This explorative study detected a high variability of knot tying techniques among German surgeons. In the absence of any evidence of the superiority of one particular technique, continuing education should focus on the quality of each single knot and perfect the details of the technique used.
Abbreviations
- PCC:
-
Primary care center
- SCC:
-
Secondary care center
- TCC:
-
Tertiary care center
References
Barnes RW, Lang NP, Whiteside MF (1989) Halstedian technique revisited. Innovations in teaching surgical skills. Ann Surg 210:118–121
Nockemann PF (1992) Die chirurgische Naht. Georg Thiema Verlag Stuttgart, New York
Tytherleigh MG, Bhatti TS, Watkins RM, Wilkins DC (2001) The assessment of surgical skills and a simple knot-tying exercise. Ann R Coll Surg Engl 83:69–73
Beard JD, Jolly BC, Newble DI, Thomas WE, Donnelly J, Southgate LJ (2005) Assessing the technical skills of surgical trainees. Br J Surg 92:778–782
Trimbos JB, Brohim R, van Rijssel EJ (1989) Factors relating to the volume of surgical knots. Int J Gynaecol Obstet 30:355–359
van Rijssel EJ, Trimbos JB, Booster MH (1990) Mechanical performance of square knots and sliding knots in surgery: comparative study. Am J Obstet Gynecol 162:93–97
Shaw AD, Duthie GS (1995) A simple assessment of surgical sutures and knots. J R Coll Surg Edinb 40:388–391
Brown RP (1992) Knotting technique and suture materials. Br J Surg 79:399–400
Gunderson PE (1987) The half-hitch knot: a rational alternative to the square knot. Am J Surg 154:538–540
Jha PK, Barabas AG, Sharma H (2007) Surgical technique. The ambidextrous surgeon’s knot: an alternate way to tie the surgeon’s knot. Can J Surg 50:470–471
Tera H, Aberg C (1976) Tensile strengths of twelve types of knot employed in surgery, using different suture materials. Acta Chir Scand 142:1–7
Zimmer CA, Thacker JG, Powell DM, Bellian KT, Becker DG, Rodeheaver GT, Edlich RF (1991) Influence of knot configuration and tying technique on the mechanical performance of sutures. J Emerg Med 9:107–113
Richey ML, Roe SC (2005) Assessment of knot security in continuous intradermal wound closures. J Surg Res 123:284–288
Ivy JJ, Unger JB, Hurt J, Mukherjee D (2004) The effect of number of throws on knot security with nonidentical sliding knots. Am J Obstet Gynecol 191:1618–1620
Behm T, Unger JB, Ivy JJ, Mukherjee D (2007) Flat square knots: are 3 throws enough? Am J Obstet Gynecol 197:172–173
Hassinger SM, Wongworawat MD, Hechanova JW (2006) Biomechanical characteristics of 10 arthroscopic knots. Arthroscopy 22:827–832
Burkhart SS, Wirth MA, Simonich M, Salem D, Lanctot D, Athanasiou K (2000) Knot security in simple sliding knots and its relationship to rotator cuff repair: how secure must the knot be? Arthroscopy 16:202–207
Murphy DL (2001) Endoscopic suturing and knot tying: theory into practice. Ann Surg 234:607–612
Sharp HT, Dorsey JH (1997) The 4-S modification of the Roeder knot: how to tie it. Obstet Gynecol 90:1004–1006
Amortegui JD, Restrepo H (2002) Knot security in laparoscopic surgery. A comparative study with conventional knots. Surg Endosc 16:1598–1602
Nottage WM, Lieurance RK (1999) Arthroscopic knot typing techniques. Arthroscopy 15:515–521
Lee AC, Fahmy RR, Hanna GB (2008) Objective evidence for optimum knot configuration. World J Surg 32:2736–2741
Schaffer SR (1984) The surgeon’s knot tied with one hand. Surg Gynecol Obstet 159:171–172
Ullman PM (1992) A new double-turn one-hand knot. Surg Gynecol Obstet 175:178–180
Stott PM, Ripley LG, Lavelle MA (2007) The ultimate Aberdeen knot. Ann R Coll Surg Engl 89:713–717
Arias J, Aller MA, Arias J (2000) A new technique for tying the surgeon’s knot. Eur J Surg 166:577–578
Alzacko SM, Majid OW (2007) "Security loop" tie: a new technique to overcome loosening of surgical knots. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod 104:e1–e4
Dinsmore RC (1995) Understanding surgical knot security: a proposal to standardize the literature. J Am Coll Surg 180:689–699
Trimbos JB (1984) Security of various knots commonly used in surgical practice. Obstet Gynecol 64:274–280
Aanning HL, Haas T, Jorgensen DR, Wulf CA (2007) Square not a running knot. J Am Coll Surg 204:422–425
Thomas RE, Crutcher R, Lorenzetti D (2007) A systematic review of the methodological quality and outcomes of RCTs to teach medical undergraduates surgical and emergency procedures. Can J Surg 50:278–290
Rogers DA, Regehr G, Howdieshell TR, Yeh KA, Palm E (2000) The impact of external feedback on computer-assisted learning for surgical technical skill training. Am J Surg 179:341–343
Rogers DA, Regehr G, Yeh KA, Howdieshell TR (1998) Computer-assisted learning versus a lecture and feedback seminar for teaching a basic surgical technical skill. Am J Surg 175:508–510
Holmlund DE (1974) Knot properties of surgical suture materials. Method study. Eur Surg Res 6:65–71
Snow SN, Dortzbach R, Moyer D (1991) Managing common suturing problems. J Dermatol Surg Oncol 17:502–508
Kim JC, Lee YK, Lim BS, Rhee SH, Yang HC (2007) Comparison of tensile and knot security properties of surgical sutures. J Mater Sci Mater Med 18:2363–2369
Brouwers JE, Oosting H, de HD, Klopper PJ (1991) Dynamic loading of surgical knots. Surg Gynecol Obstet 173:443–448
Batra EK, Taylor PT, Franz DA, Towler MA, Edlich RF (1993) A portable tensiometer for assessing surgeon’s knot tying technique. Gynecol Oncol 48:114–118
Rodeheaver GT, Green CW, Odum BC, Bussard GM, Edlich RF (1998) Technical considerations in knot construction, part III. Knot asymmetry. J Emerg Med 16:635–639
Schubert DC, Unger JB, Mukherjee D, Perrone JF (2002) Mechanical performance of knots using braided and monofilament absorbable sutures. Am J Obstet Gynecol 187:1438–1440
Heermann JB (1971) Tensile strenght and knot security of surgical suture materials. Am J Surg 37:209–217
Lunstedt B, Debus S, Thiede A (1993) Healing of the anastomosis in various suture techniques in the gastrointestinal tract. Physiology, experimental and clinical results. Zentralbl Chir 118:1–7
Knaebel HP, Koch M, Sauerland S, Diener MK, Buchler MW, Seiler CM (2005) Interrupted or continuous slowly absorbable sutures—design of a multi-centre randomised trial to evaluate abdominal closure techniques INSECT-trial [ISRCTN24023541]. BMC Surg 5:3
Hurt J, Unger JB, Ivy JJ, Mukherjee D, Pizzaro A (2005) Tying a loop-to-strand suture: is it safe? Am J Obstet Gynecol 192:1094–1097
Ind TE, Shelton JC, Shepherd JH (2001) Influence of training on reliability of surgical knots. BJOG 108:1013–1016
Trimbos JB, van Rijssel EJ, Klopper PJ (1986) Performance of sliding knots in monofilament and multifilament suture material. Obstet Gynecol 68:425–430
Revington P, Bowyer RC (1994) Sutures: the economics of knot tying techniques. Ann R Coll Surg Engl 76:281
Thust W (1997) Jetzt 343556 Ärztinnen und Ärzte. Deutsches Ärzteblatt, Supplement 94:3–19
Deutsche Krankenhausgesellschaft. Krankenhausstatistik. www.dkgev.de/dkg.php/aid/3455/cat/62. 23-10-2007. Ref type: data file
Bundesärztekammer (2005) Die ärztliche Versorgung in der Bundesrepublik Deutschland [Online]
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Hanns-Peter Knaebel is currently the CEO of Aesculap AG, Germany. The authors have no other involvement, financial or otherwise, that might potentially bias their work.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Fischer, L., Bruckner, T., Müller-Stich, B.P. et al. Variability of surgical knot tying techniques: do we need to standardize?. Langenbecks Arch Surg 395, 445–450 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00423-009-0575-8
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00423-009-0575-8