Abstract
Purpose The purpose was to establish the impact on survival of early detection of a local recurrence of breast cancer as compared to late detection. Design A meta-analysis was carried out using Cochrane review manager software (RevMan version 4.2). Studies were included if women were treated for primary breast cancer without evidence of distant metastasis at primary diagnosis and if these concerned routine follow-up strategies focusing on the early detection of curable recurrences. Data regarding the risk for death were derived from each study. Multi level models were used to study heterogeneity by using MLWin. Results Thirteen studies concerning 2,263 patients were included. Early detection of breast cancer recurrences during follow-up gave a significantly better survival as compared to late detected recurrences (HR: 1.68 (95% CI: 1.48–1.91)). Survival was better when the recurrence was found by mammography instead of physical examination or in patients without symptoms as compared to those with symptoms (HR: 2.44 (95% CI: 1.78–3.35); HR: 1.56 (95% CI: 1.36–1.79), respectively). If all breast cancer recurrences would be detected earlier, that 5–8 deaths (i.e. an absolute reduction in mortality of 17–28%) would be avoided by performing routine follow-up during a 10 year-period for 1,000 breast cancer patients. Conclusion These data support the hypothesis that detection of isolated loco-regional or contra-lateral breast cancer recurrences in patients without symptoms has beneficial impact on survival of breast cancer patients when compared to late symptomatic detection.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Parkin DM, Fernandez LM (2006) Use of statistics to assess the global burden of breast cancer. Breast J 12(Suppl 1):S70–S80
Hiramanek N (2004) Breast cancer recurrence: follow up after treatment for primary breast cancer. Postgrad Med J 80:172–176
Erikson C, Salsberg E, Forte G et al (2007) Future supply and demand for oncologists-challenges to assuring access to oncology services. J Oncol Practice 3:79–86
Schapira DV, Urban N (1991) A minimalist policy for breast cancer surveillance. JAMA 265:380–382
De Bock GH, Bonnema J, Van Der Hage J et al (2004) Effectiveness of routine visits and routine tests in detecting isolated locoregional recurrences after treatment for early-stage invasive breast cancer: a meta-analysis and systematic review. J Clin Oncol 22:4010–4018
Kemperman H, Borger J, Hart A et al (1995) Prognostic factors for survival after breast conserving therapy for stage I and II breast cancer. The role of local recurrence. Eur J Cancer 31:690–698
Clarke M, Collins R, Darby S et al (2005) Early Breast Cancer Trialists’ Collaborative Group (EBCTCG). Effects of radiotherapy and of differences in the extent of surgery for early breast cancer on local recurrence and 15-year survival: an overview of the randomised trials. Lancet 366:2087–2106
Te Boekhorst DS, Peer NG, van der Sluis RF et al (2001) Periodic follow-up after breast cancer and the effect on survival. Eur J Surg 167:490–496
Rutgers EJ, van Slooten EA, Kluck HM (1989) Follow-up after treatment of primary breast cancer. Br J Surg 76:187–190
Dewar JA, Kerr GR (1985) Value of routine follow up of women treated for early carcinoma of the breast. Brit Med J (Clin Res Ed) 291:1464–1467
Ciatto S, Rosselli Del Turco M, Pacini P et al (1985) Early detection of breast cancer recurrences through periodic follow-up—is it useless? Tumori 71:325–329
Broyn T, Froyen J (1982) Evaluation of routine follow-up after surgery for breast carcinoma. Acta Chir Scand 148:401–404
Krengli M, Pastore G, Maffei S (1993) The importance of the follow-up in patients operated on for breast cancer. A retrospective analysis of 2,482 cases. Minerva Med 84:409–415
Pivot X, Asmar L, Hortobagyi GN et al (2000) A retrospective study of first indicators of breast cancer recurrence. Oncology 58:185–190
Altman DG, Lyman GH (1998) Methodological challenges in the evaluation of prognostic factors in breast cancer. Breast Cancer Res Treat 52:289–303
Laupacis A, Wells G, Richardson WS et al (1994) Users’ guides to the medical literature, V: how to use an article on prognosis. JAMA 272:234–237
Begg CB, Mazumdar M (1994) Operating characteristics of a rank correlation test for publication bias. Biometrics 50:1088–1101
Rosenberg MS (2005) The file drawer problem revisited: a general weighted method for calculating fail-safe number in meta-analysis. Evolution Int J Org Evolution 59:464–468
Parmar MKB, Torri V, Stewart L (1998) Extracting summary statistics to perform meta-analyses of the published literature for survival endpoint. Statist Med 17:2815–2834
Ciatto S, Miccinesi G, Zappa M (2004) Prognostic impact of the early detection of metachronous contralateral breast cancer. Eur J Cancer 40:1496–1501
Breslow NE, Day NE (1980) Statistical methods in cancer research. Volume I—The analysis of case-control studies. IARC Sci Publ 32:5–338
Soerjomataram I, Louwman MW, Ribot JG, Roukema JA, Coebergh JW (2008) An overview of prognostic factors for long-term survivors of breast cancer. Breast Cancer Res Treat 107:309–330
Doyle T, Schultz DJ, Peters C et al (2001) Long-term results of local recurrence after breast conservation treatment for invasive breast cancer. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 51:74–80
Imoto S, Jitsuiki Y (1998) Detection of the first recurrence during intensive follow-up of breast cancer patients. Jpn J Clin Oncol 28:597–600
Kindler M, Steinhoff G (1989) Follow-up of breast cancer patients. Oncology 46:360–365
Stierer M, Rosen HR (1989) Influence of early diagnosis on prognosis of recurrent breast cancer. Cancer 64:1128–1131
Orel SG, Fowble BL, Solin LJ et al (1993) Breast cancer recurrence after lumpectomy and radiation therapy for early-stage disease: prognostic significance of detection method. Radiology 188:189–194
Wagman LD, Sanders RD, Terz JJ et al (1991) The value of symptom directed evaluation in the surveillance for recurrence of carcinoma of the breast. Surg Gynecol Obst 172:191–196
Voogd AC, van Tienhoven G, Peterse HL et al (1999) Local recurrence after breast conservation therapy for early stage breast carcinoma: detection, treatment, and outcome in 266 patients. Dutch Study Group on Local Recurrence after Breast Conservation (BORST). Cancer 85:437–446
Mellink W, Holland R, Hendrisks T (1991) The contribution of routine follow-up mammography to an early detection of a synchronous contralateral breast cancer. Cancer 67:1844–1848
Lash TL, Clough-Gorr K, Silliman RA (2006) Reduced mortality rate associated with annual mammograms after breast cancer therapy. Breast J 12:2–6
Kaas R, Hart AA, Besnard AP et al (2001) Impact of mammographic interval on stage and survival after the diagnosis of contralateral breast cancer. Br J Surg 88:123–127
Montgomery DA, Krupa K, Jack WJL et al (2007) Changing pattern of the detection of locoregional relapse in breast cancer: the Edinburgh experience. Brit J Cancer 96:1802–1807
Hussian ST, Gui GP, Lee KS et al (1995) Detection of loco-regional recurrence after breast-conserving surgery and radiotherapy. J R Coll Surg Edinb 40:163–166
Khatcheressian JL, Wolff AC, Smith TJ et al (2006) American Society of Clinical Oncology 2006 update of the breast cancer follow-up and management guidelines in the adjuvant setting. J Clin Oncol 24:5091–5097
Perrone MA, Musolino A, Michiara M et al (2004) Early detection of recurrences in the follow-up of primary breast cancer in an asymptomatic or symptomatic phase. Tumori 90:276–279
Tomin R, Donegan WL (1987) Screening for recurrent breast cancer–its effectiveness and prognostic value. J Clin Oncol 5:62–67
Rosselli Del Turco M, Palli D, Cariddi A et al (1994) Intensive diagnostic follow-up after treatment of primary breast cancer. A randomized trial. National Research Council Project on Breast Cancer follow-up. JAMA 271:1593–1597
The GIVIO Investigators (1994) Impact of follow-up testing on survival and health-related quality of life in breast cancer patients. A multicenter randomized controlled trial. JAMA 271:1587–1592
Ciatto S, Ambrogetti D, Bonardi R et al (1990) Prognostic impact of early detection of contralateral primary breast cancer. Tumori 76:370–373
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Lu, W.L., Jansen, L., Post, W.J. et al. Impact on survival of early detection of isolated breast recurrences after the primary treatment for breast cancer: a meta-analysis. Breast Cancer Res Treat 114, 403–412 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10549-008-0023-4
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10549-008-0023-4