Abstract
Consultations with community-based service providers in Toronto identified a lack of strong research evidence about successful community-based interventions that address the needs of homeless clients experiencing concurrent mental health and substance use disorders. We undertook a collaborative research effort between academic-based and community-based partners to conduct a systematic evidence synthesis drawing heavily from Pawson’s realist review methodology to focus on both whether programs are successful and why and how they lead to improved outcomes. We examined scholarly and nonscholarly literature to explore program approaches and program elements that lead to improvements in mental health and substance use disorders among homeless individuals with concurrent disorders (CD). Information related to program contexts, elements, and successes and failures were extracted and further supplemented by key informant interviews and author communication regarding reviewed published studies. From the ten programs that we reviewed, we identified six important and promising program strategies that reduce mental health and, to a far lesser degree, substance use problems: client choice in treatment decision-making, positive interpersonal relationships between client and provider, assertive community treatment approaches, providing supportive housing, providing supports for instrumental needs, and nonrestrictive program approaches. These promising program strategies function, in part, by promoting and supporting autonomy among homeless adults experiencing CD. Our realist informed review is a useful methodology for synthesizing complex programming information on community-based interventions.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
Community agencies forming the partnership with CRICH: Access Alliance; Ontario Federation of Indian Friendship Centres; Sistering, a Women’s Place; Street Health; South Riverdale Community Health Centre.
CRICH faculty and research fellows had expertise in the following areas: social epidemiology, biostatistics, clinical psychology, sociology, family medicine, aboriginal health, ethics, public health sciences, knowledge translation, and social work.
References
National Law Center on Homelessness and Poverty. Homelessness in the United States and the Human Right to Housing; 2004.
Urban Institute. A New Look at Homelessness in America. Available from the Urban Institute, 2100 M Street, N.W., Washington, DC, 20037 or available at: http://www.urban.org.
Hwang SW. Homelessness and health. Can Med Assoc J. 2001; 164(2): 229-233.
National Coalition for the Homeless 2006a. Health Care and Homelessness NCH Fact Sheet #8. Available at: http://www.nationalhomeless.org. Accessed on June, 1 2008.
Street Health. The Street Health Report. Available at: http://www.streethealth.ca/Downloads/SHReport2007.pdf.
Lehman AF, Cordray DS. Prevalence of alcohol, drug, and mental disorders among the homeless: one more time. Contemp Drug Probl. 1993; 20: 355-383.
National Coalition for the Homeless 2006b. Mental Illness and Homelessness NCH Fact Sheet #5. Available at: http://www.nationalhomeless.org. Accessed on June, 1 2008.
National Resource and Training Center on Homelessness and Mental Illness 2003. Get the Facts. Available at: http://www.nrchmi.samhsa.gov. Accessed on June, 1 2008.
Smith EM, North CS, Spitznagel EL. A systematic study of mental illness, substance abuse, and treatment in 600 homeless men. Ann Clin Psychiatry. 1992; 4: 111-120.
Toro PA, ed. Homelessness. New York: Pergamon; 1998. Bellack AS, Hersen M, eds. Comprehensive Clinical Psychology, Ch. 8 in Vol. 9, Applications in diverse populations (pp. 119–135).
Toro PA, Wall DD. Research on homeless persons: diagnostic comparisons and practice implications. Prof Psychol Res Pract. 1991; 22(6): 479-488.
Toro PA. Toward an international understanding of homelessness. J Soc Issues. 2007; 63(3): 461-481.
Drake RE, Osher FC, Wallach MA. Homelessness and dual diagnosis. Am Psychol. 1991; 46(11): 1149-1158.
Regier DA, Farmer ME, Rae DS, Locke BZ, Keith SJ, Judd LL. Comorbidity of mental disorders with alcohol and other drug abuse. Results from the Epidemiologic Catchment Area (ECA) Study. J Am Med Assoc. 1990; 264: 2511-2518.
Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration [SAMHSA]. Report to Congress on the Prevention and Treatment of Co-Occurring Substance Use Disorders and Mental Disorders. Washington, DC; 2003.
Buckner JC, Bassuk E, Zima B. Mental health issues affecting homeless women: implications for intervention. Am J Orthopsychiatry. 1993; 63(6): 385-399.
Drake RE, Yovetich NA, Bebout RR, Harris M, McHugo GJ. Integrated treatment for dually diagnosed homeless adults. J Nerv Ment Dis. 1997; 185(5): 298-305.
Eberle M, Kraus D, Serge L, Pomeroy S, Hulchanski D. Homelessness—Causes and Effects. Victoria: Ministry of Social Development and Economic Security and BC Housing Management Commission; 2001.
Serge L, Kraus D, Goldberg M. Services to Homeless People with Concurrent Disorders: Moving Towards Innovative Approaches. Vancouver, Canada: 2006.
Gelberg L, Linn LS, Usatine RP, Smith MH. Health, homelessness and poverty. A study of clinic users. Arch Int Med. 1990; 150: 2325-2330.
Goering P, Pyke J, Bullock H. Health, Mental Health, and Addiction Treatment Needs of People Using Emergency Shelters in Toronto. City of Toronto; 2004.
Goering P, Tolomiczenko G, Sheldon T, Boydell K, Wasylenki D. Characteristics of persons who are homeless for the first time. Psychiatr Serv. 2002; 53: 1472-1474.
O’Toole TP, Gibbon JL, Hanusa BH, Fine MJ. Preferences for sites of care among urban homeless and housed poor adults. J Gen Intern Med. 1999; 14(10): 599-605.
Denis JL, Lomas J. Convergent evolution: the academic and policy roots of collaborative research. J Health Serv Res Policy. 2003; 8(Suppl 2): 1-6.
Dobrow MJ, Goel V, Upshur RE. Evidence-based health policy: context and utilisation. Soc Sci Med. 2004; 58(1): 207-217.
Graham ID, Logan L, Harrison M, et al. Lost in knowledge translation: time for a map? J Contin Educ Health Prof. 2006; 26: 13-24.
Innvaer SGV, Trommald MAO. Health policy-makers’ pecrceptons of their use of evidence: a systematic review. J Health Serv Res Policy. 2002; 7: 239-244.
Jacobson N, Butterill D, Goering P. Development of a framework for KT: understanding user context. J Health Serv Res Policy. 2003; 8(2): 94-99.
Landry R, Lamari M, Amara N. Extent and determinants of utilization of university research in government agencies. Publ Admin Rev. 2003; 63(2): 193-205.
Lavis JN, Robertson D, Woodside J, McLeodm C, Abelson J. Knowledge Transfer Research Group. How can research organizations more effectively transfer research knowledge to decision makers? Milbank Q. 2003; 81: 171-172.
Drake RE, O’Neal EL, Wallach MA. A systematic review of psychosocial research on psychosocial interventions for people with co-occurring severe mental and substance use disorders. J Subst Abuse Treat. 2008; 34(1): 123-138.
Dixon-Woods M, Agaral S, Jones D, Young B, Sutton A. Synthesising qualitative and quantitative evidence: a review of possible methods. J Health Serv Res Policy. 2005; 10(1): 45-53.
Mays N, Pope C, Popay J. Systematically reviewing qualitative and quantitative evidence to inform management and policy-making in the health field. J Health Serv Res Policy. 2005; 10(1): 6-20.
Petticrew M, Roberts H. Systematic Reviews in the Social Sciences: A Practical Guide. Oxford: Blackwell; 2006.
Pawson R, Greenhalgh T, Harvey G, Walshe K. Realist review: a new method of systematic review designed for complex policy interventions. J Health Serv Res Policy. 2005; 10(S1): 21-34.
Dixon-Woods M, Shaw RL, Agarwal S, Smith JA. The problem of appraising qualitative research. Qual Saf Health Care. 2004; 13: 223-225.
Popay J, Roberts H, Sowden A, et al. Guidance on the Conduct of Narrative Synthesis in Systematic Reviews: A Product from the ESRC Methods Programme. Lancaster: Institute for Health Research, Lancaster University; 2006.
Spencer L, Ritchie J, Lewis J, Dillon L. Quality in Qualitative Evaluation: A Framework for Assessing Research Evidence. London, UK; 2003.
Pawson R. Evidence-Based Policy: A Realist Perspective. London: Sage; 2006.
Arai L, Roen K, Roberts H, Popay J. It might work in Oklahoma but will it work in Oakhampton? Context and implementation in the effectiveness literature on domestic smoke detectors. Inj Prev. 2005; 11: 148-151.
Blankertz LE, Cnaan RA. Assessing the impact of two residential programs for dually diagnosed homeless individuals. Soc Serv Rev. 1994; 68: 536-560.
Cnaan RA, Blankertz L, Messinger KW, Gardner JR. Psychosocial rehabilitation: toward a definition. Psychosoc Rehabil J. 1988; 11(4): 61-77.
Lovell AN, Cohen M. The elaboration of “choice” in a program for homeless persons labeled psychiatrically disabled. Human Organ. 1998; 57(1): 8-20.
Greenwood R, Schaefer-McDaniel N, Winkel G, Tsemberis SJ. Decreasing psychiatric symptoms by increasing choice in services for adults with histories of homelessness. Am J Community Psychol. 2005; 36(3/4): 223-238.
Calsyn RJ, Morse GA, Klinkenberg WD, Lemming MR. Client outcomes and the working alliance in Assertive Community Treatment programs. Care Manage J. 2004; 5(4): 199-202.
Shern DL, Tsemberis S, Anthony W, et al. Serving street-dwelling individuals with psychiatric disabilities: outcomes of a psychiatric rehabilitation clinical trial. Am J Public Health. 2000; 90(12): 1873-1878.
Padgett DK, Henwood B, Abrams C, Davis A. Engagement and retention in care among formerly homeless adults with serious mental illness: voices from the margins. Psychiatr Rehabil J. 2008; 31(3): 226-233.
Morse GA, Calsyn RJ, Klinkenberg WD, et al. Treating homeless clients with severe mental illness and substance use disorders: costs and outcomes. Community Ment Health J. 2006; 42(4): 377-403.
Essock SM, Mueser KT, Drake RE, et al. Comparison of ACT and standard case management for delivering integrated treatment for co-occurring disorders. Psychiatr Serv. 2006; 57: 185-196.
Meisler N, Blankertz L, Santos AB, McKay C. Impact of assertive community treatment on homeless persons with co-occurring severe psychiatric and substance use disorders. Community Ment Health J. 1997; 33(2): 113-122.
Tsemberis S, Moran L, Shinn B, Shern D, Asmussen S. Consumer preference programs for individuals who are homeless and have psychiatric disabilities: a drop-in center and a supported housing program. Am J Community Psychol. 2003; 32(3/4): 305-317.
Giddens A. Consequences of Modernity. Oxford: Polity; 1990.
Laing RD. The Divided Self: An Existential Study in Sanity and Madness. London: Pelican; 1965.
Padgett DK. There’s no place like (a) home: ontological security among persons with serious mental illness in the United States. Soc Sci Med. 2007; 64: 1925-1936.
Dupuis A, Thorns DC. Home, home ownership, and the search for ontological security. Socio Rev. 1998; 46(1): 24-47.
Burnam MA, Morton SC, McGlynn EA, et al. An experimental evaluation of residential and nonresidential treatment for dually diagnosed homeless adults. J Addict Dis. 1995; 149(4): 111-134.
Harper E. Making good choices: how autonomy support influences the behavior change and motivation of troubled and troubling youth. Reclaiming Children and Youth. 2007; 16(3): 23-28.
Miquelon P, Vallerand R. Goal motives, well-being, and physical health: an integrative model. Can Psychol. 2008; 49(3): 241-249.
Ryan R, Deci E. Self-determination theory and the facilitation of intrinsic motivation, social development, and well-being. Am Psychol. 2000; 55(1): 68-78.
Williams G, Gagne M, Mushlin A, Deci E. Motivation for behaviour change in patients with chest pain. Health Educ. 2005; 106(4): 304-321.
White KR. The transition from victim to victor: an application of the theory of mastery. J Psychosoc Nurs Ment Health Serv. 1995; 33(8): 41-44.
Pawson R, Tilley N. Realistic Evaluation. London: Sage; 1997.
Pawson R, Greenhalgh T, Harvey G, Walshe K. Realist Synthesis: An Introduction. ESRC Research Methods Programme Working Paper Series. UK: University of Manchester; 2004.
Connelly J, Duaso M, Butler G. A systematic review of controlled trials of interventions to prevent childhood obesity and overweight: a realistic synthesis of the evidence. Publ Health. 2007; 121: 510-517.
Greenhalgh T, Kristjansson ERV. Realist review to understand the efficacy of school feeding programs. BMJ. 2007; 335: 858-861.
Pawson R. Does Megan’s Law Work? A Theory Drive systematic Review. ESRC UK Centre for Evidence Based Policy and Practice: Working Paper 8. London; 2002.
Egan M, Bambra C, Petticrew M, Whitehead M. Reviewing evidence on complex social interventions: appraising implementation in systematic reviews of the health effects of organisational-level workplace interventions. J Epidemiol Community Health. 2009; 63: 4-11.
Herbert R, Bo K. Analysis of quality of interventions in systematic reviews. BMJ. 2005; 331(3): 507-509.
Tsemberis S, Gulcur L, Nakae M. Housing first, consumer choice, and harm reduction for homeless individuals with a dual diagnosis. Am J Public Health. 2004; 94(4): 651-656.
Padgett D, Gulcur L, Tsemberis S. Housing first services for people who are homeless with co-occurring serious mental illness and substance abuse. Res Soc Work Pract. 2006; 16(1): 74-83.
Srebnik D, Livingston J, Gordon L, King D. Housing choice and community success for individuals with serious and persistent mental illness. Community Ment Health J. 1995; 31(2): 139-152.
Shern DL, Tsemberis S, Winarski J, Cope N, Cohen M, Anthony W. The effectiveness of psychiatric rehabilitation for persons who are street dwelling with serious disability related to mental illness. In: In Breakey WR, Thompson JW, eds. Mentally Ill and Homeless. Amsterdam: Harwood Academic; 1997: 119-147.
McHugo GJ, Bebout RR, Harris M, et al. A randomized controlled trial of integrated versus parallel housing services for homeless adults with severe mental illness. Schizophr Bull. 2004; 30(4): 969-982.
Essock SM, Frisman LK, Kontos NJ. Cost-effectiveness of assertive community treatment teams. Am J Orthopsychiatry. 1998; 68(2): 179-190.
Essock SM, Kontos N. Implementing assertive community treatment teams. Psychiatr Serv. 1995; 46: 679-683.
Stecher BM, Andrews CA, McDonald L, et al. Implementation of residential and non-residential treatment for the dually diagnosed homeless. Eval Rev. 1994; 18(6): 689-717.
Anonymous. Supportive residential services to reunite homeless mentally ill single parents with their children. Psychiatr Serv. 2000; 51(11): 1433–1435.
Mares AS, Rosenheck RA. One-year housing arrangements among homeless adults with serious mental illness in the ACCESS program. Psychiatr Serv. 2004; 55(5): 566-574.
Bebout RR. Housing solutions. The community connections housing program: Preventing homelessness by integrating housing and supports. Alcohol. Treat Q. (1999); 17(1): 93-112.
Blankertz L, White KK. Implementation of rehabilitation program for dually diagnosed homeless. Alcohol. Treat Q. (1990); 7(1): 149-164.
Acknowledgements
This research was supported by a Canadian Institutes for Health Research Strategic Training Initiative in Health Research grant (STO-64598), the Ontario Ministry of Health and Long Term Care, and the Alma and Baxter Ricard Chair in Inner City Health (PO). We would like to thank the following individuals who participated in the research activities: Gladis Chow, Susan Clancy, Jessica Hill, Axelle Janczur, Erika Khandor, Kelly Murphy, Rosane Nisenbaum, Lynne Raskin, Anjali Sharma, Janet Smylie, Melissa Tapper, Charoula Tsamis, Qamar Zaidi, Carolyn Ziegler, and Marcqueline Chiona Zulu.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
O’Campo, P., Kirst, M., Schaefer-McDaniel, N. et al. Community-Based Services for Homeless Adults Experiencing Concurrent Mental Health and Substance Use Disorders: A Realist Approach to Synthesizing Evidence. J Urban Health 86, 965–989 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11524-009-9392-1
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11524-009-9392-1