The influence of street lighting improvements on crime, fear and pedestrian street use, after dark
Abstract
This paper focuses upon the results of a co-ordinated programme of research designed to evaluate the impact of street lighting improvements on crime and fear of crime. The street lighting was upgraded in three urban streets and a pedestrian footpath considered by a multi-agency team to be crime and fear prone. The impact of the street lighting programme was assessed using attitudinal and behavioural measures, through ‘before’ and ‘after’ surveys of pedestrians. The results provide convincing evidence that sensitively deployed street lighting can lead to reductions in crime and fear of crime, and increase pedestrian street use after dark.
References (12)
- D.I. Bainbridge et al.
The Impact of Public Lighting on Crime, Fear of Crime and Quality of Life: a Study in the Moseley and Showell Green Areas of Birmingham
(1993) - R.V.G. Clarke et al.
Diffusion of crime control benefits: observations on the reverse of displacement
- P.M. Mayhew et al.
Crime in Public View
- P.M. Mayhew et al.
The 1992 British Crime Survey
- K. Painter
Lighting and Crime Prevention: the Edmonton Project
(1988)
Cited by (232)
Measuring energy access for livelihoods, lifestyles, and welfare: Validating the Hierarchical Energy Access Framework in India
2024, Energy Research and Social ScienceHousehold energy poverty is a multi-dimensional issue that extends to any service a household would like to obtain that requires energy, not just those at the household level. It is crucial to incorporate this understanding in how household energy access is measured to adequately inform any measure taken to address this issue. In recent years, a few methodologies, like the Multi-tier Framework, have been designed to reflect this thinking. However, their widespread adoption has been lacklustre primarily due to their use of complicated and yet-unmeasured parameters. Therefore, a readily deployable measurement framework in this vein remains absent from literature. This paper addresses this gap by showcasing a new household energy access measurement methodology, named the Hierarchical Energy Access Framework (HEAF) which assesses service gained by households across four hierarchical states of energy access and across four avenues of energy use, viz., household level services, productive endeavours, transportation, and community facilities. It achieves this using simple but comprehensive indicators specifically designed to be operationalizable using publicly available government-generated data. To illustrate its utility, energy access in rural Indian households in 2011 has been estimated. The results indicate that they were transitioning to modern energy sources in a highly unequal fashion both within and across the avenues of energy use considered, and 25.69 % of them were facing abject energy poverty. Overall, data availability for deploying the HEAF in India was found to be largely adequate, except for street lighting. A discussion has also been made on the global applicability of the HEAF.
Streetscapes as part of servicescapes: Can walkable streetscapes make local businesses more attractive?
2023, Computers, Environment and Urban SystemsAttractive local businesses can make cities more walkable by providing desirable destinations to walk to. The term servicescape has been used to describe the physical settings and environments that affect customers' inference of the service quality of businesses at that location. This study extends the concept of servicescapes to include walkable streetscapes and examines whether features that make streets more walkable also make local businesses on those streets more attractive. This study measures walkable streetscape features using street view images and computer vision, which are associated with customer satisfaction values derived from Yelp review scores of restaurants in Atlanta, GA, USA. After controlling for various covariates including pedestrian accessibility, restaurant type, and neighborhood-specific characteristics, this study found sidewalk buffers, greenness at eye level, and building-to-street ratio as streetscape features positively associated with customer satisfaction. Planning tools for promoting walkable streetscapes are discussed to improve the street vibrancy and the economic opportunities of local businesses.
How to light up the night? The impact of city park lighting on visitors’ sense of safety and preferences
2023, Urban Forestry and Urban GreeningThis article presents the results of research that seeks to further our understanding of how lighting methods used in city parks impact sense of safety and preferences. We studied how the impact varies according to: (1) the lighting of paths as well as horizontal and vertical space; (2) foreground and background lighting. At the same time, we checked how the impact of these lighting features on sense of safety and preferences may be explained by mystery, legibility and a sense of privacy. We employed a within-subjects design in which 143 participants evaluated a set of 120 eye-level photographs of park landscapes in terms of mystery, legibility, perceived privacy and safety, and preference. We measured the degree of illumination in the photos as a percentage coverage of illuminated landscape forms. We tested the hypotheses by analysing a number of mediation models. The results revealed that the impact of lighting on perceived safety was explained by legibility. Safety (and legibility) increased along with increased lighting of landscape forms, but only in the background. Increased lighting of paths did not affect safety. An increase in path lighting lowered preferences because it deprived the landscape of mystery and privacy. Increasing the lighting around paths raised the assessment of mystery and, therefore, preference, but this only involved the lighting of vertical elements. Background lighting made the landscape more attractive because it became more legible and mysterious, and provided a greater safety and privacy. Foreground lighting had the opposite effect (it lowered the ratings).
Key environmental factors affecting perceptions of security of night-time walking in neighbourhood streets: A discussion based on fear heat maps
2023, Journal of Transport and HealthWalking plays an important role in residents’ health. After experiencing rapid development, most cities in China have gradually entered the process of urban renewal. Therefore, improving the quality of neighbourhood streets in the old city has become an important issue. The sense of security at night has become an important part of street reconstruction. Therefore, finding out the key environmental factors that affect the security of night-time walking in the streets of the old city has become an important prerequisite for street reconstruction.
Firstly, according to the theoretical explanation of security in the existing literature, the environmental variables that may affect the security of night-time walking are determined. Besides, we chose the typical neighbourhood streets in the old town that need to be improved urgently, and recruited 32 subjects in an on-site experiment to record. Through wearable devices, the galvanic skin response, (GPS), and panoramic video signals generated by the subject during the experiment. The high arousal environment nodes of the subjects were determined by Galvanic skin response GSR signal and GPS signal. According to the semi-structured interview of the subjects, we valenced these high-arousal environment nodes and established a map of each subject’s fear emotional environment nodes. Aggregated into a street walking fear map by kernel density estimation. Finally, we selected the environment nodes with different degrees of fear on the map, established the optimal regression model of night-time walking security through the optimal subset regression method, and finally identified the critical environmental factors.
The key environmental influences are street transparency, illegal parking level, environmental cleanliness level, light-transmittance intensity form building, CCTV density, and crowd activity intensity. The above key factors suggest that theEyes on the Street (EoS) theory seems to occupy a more important position in the relevant theories of street night-time security research. It also suggests that the privacy of subjects needs to be considered when improving the security of the street at night.
Effects of flicker with various brightness contrasts on visual fatigue in road lighting using fixed low-mounting-height luminaires
2023, Tunnelling and Underground Space TechnologyThe flicker effect caused by the periodical succession of bright and dark bands on the road surface and tunnel walls can momentarily distract drivers and poses a safety concern. Low-mounting-height luminaires are typically used to illuminate long underground roads. However, the resulting flicker effects persist for longer duration, which can cause accidents. Although flicker frequencies have been extensively discussed, limited studies have focused on the effect of the ratio of background brightness to luminaire surface brightness on the flicker effect in road lighting. In this study, two experiments were performed to investigate the effect of reducing brightness contrast (BC) on human visual fatigue. BC can be decreased by reducing the surface brightness of the lamp (Experiment 1) and increasing background brightness (Experiment 2). The flicker frequencies in Experiment 1 were 4 and 6 Hz, and 6 Hz in Experiment 2. The study involved 49 participants. The results revealed that the blink rate and visual fatigue change rate (VFCR) decreased with a decrease in BC. The flicker frequency of 6 Hz is more effective than that of 4 Hz by reducing the surface brightness of lamps on the VFCR. This method is more effective in reducing the brightness of the surface of the lamp than increasing the background brightness to relieve eye fatigue. The proportion of time in a minute that the eyes are at least 80% closed (P80) increases as BC increases. This study may provide guidance for urban road lighting and road lighting product design.
Effects of outdoor artificial light at night on human health and behavior: A literature review
2023, Environmental PollutionThe quality of life of human beings has improved tremendously through improved productivity, convenience, safety, and livability due to nighttime lights that illuminate outdoor work, leisure, and mobility. Recently, however, concerns have been growing over outdoor artificial light at night (ALAN) and its effects on human beings as well as ecosystems including animals and plants. This literature review aims to deliver a critical overview of the findings and the areas for future research on the effects of outdoor ALAN on human health and behaviors. Through a narrative literature review, we found that scientific research crucially lacks studies on the effects of outdoor ALAN on human behaviors and health, including social interaction, which may be more widespread compared to what is recognized so far. This review also highlights the importance of investigating the causal and complex relationships between outdoor ALAN, health, and behaviors with sleep as a key mediating factor. We elucidate that outdoor ALAN has both positive and negative effects on human life. Therefore, it is important for societies to be able to access facts and evidence about these effects to plan, agree to, and realize the optimal usage of nighttime lighting that balances its merits and demerits. Researchers in related areas of study must investigate and deliver the science of outdoor ALAN to various stakeholders, such as citizens, policymakers, urban and landscape planners, relevant practitioners, and industries. We believe that our review improves the understanding of outdoor ALAN in relation to human life and contributes to sustainable and thriving societies.