Original ArticlesDistressed women’s clinic patients:: Preferences for mental health treatments and perceived obstacles
Introduction
Many people who seek help for mental health problems visit a primary care doctor rather than a mental health specialist [1], a pattern more pronounced among low-income and ethnic minority populations 2, 3. Among low-income young women, a group at much higher risk high of developing psychiatric disorders than the general population 4, 5, many receive medical care exclusively from gynecology or family planning services [6]. Therefore, the best setting to identify, treat, and make referrals for mental health problems in distressed low-income young women may be in women’s clinics.
Given that low-income and ethnic minority women are less likely to use mental health services than their white or higher-income counterparts 7, 8, 9, it is important to understand their preferences for treatment in order to facilitate acceptance of and adherence to mental health treatment. The most common psychiatric disorder seen among gynecology patients is depression. In gynecology settings, medication is the predominant treatment for depression, used more frequently than provider counseling or referral to specialty mental health services [10]. Therefore, it is particularly important to examine the acceptability of medication treatment for depression, and for those not interested in medication, what other treatment options would be acceptable.
Only a few studies have examined mental health treatment preferences of medical patients. In a primary care sample, Cooper-Patrick et al. [11] found that depressed patients indicated the greatest preference for individual treatment, followed by medication and waiting for the depression to remit. Group therapy was the least preferred treatment option. Black patients were less likely than whites to consider medication as an acceptable treatment. In a disadvantaged, general medical clinic sample, Areán and Miranda [12] found that although patients were most interested in psychosocial treatments focused on medical problems, most were also interested in groups dealing with stress and depression. This study did not examine acceptability of medication treatment. Although similar to this general medical sample with respect to socioeconomic status (SES), the younger and exclusively female patients seen in public care OB-GYN settings may have different treatment needs. Specifically, they may have less need for services centered around chronic medical problems and greater need for services related to other psychosocial issues, such as problems with children, domestic violence, or sexual trauma. However, it is not known what types of mental health referrals low-income women’s clinic patients would find acceptable.
In addition to treatment preferences, it is also important to understand the obstacles to mental health service use in this high-risk patient population. Compared with whites and middle-class individuals, ethnic minorities and lower SES individuals identify more barriers to entering mental health treatment and express more concerns about the reactions of others and the potential for stigmatization 13, 14, 15, 16. Most studies examining these barriers have focused on community rather than clinic samples. It is not clear whether patients already accessing medical services in settings where mental health services are available would perceive similar obstacles.
In an effort to explore ways to improve mental health services to a patient population at high risk for psychiatric disorders, this study examines preference for services, including medication as well as various psychosocial treatments, and perceived obstacles to treatment among distressed low-income patients from a public care women’s clinic. Because depression is the most common psychiatric disorder seen in gynecology settings, we also examine predictors of acceptance of different interventions for depression.
Section snippets
Participants
As part of a larger study [17], 217 women were interviewed about their attitudes towards mental illness and mental health services. During this interview, women were asked about current distress: “In the past month, have you had severe enough personal, emotional, behavior, or mental problems that you felt you needed help?” [18] Women who answered no were asked a second question: “In the past month, have you had severe enough medical or health problems that you felt they were affecting your
Psychiatric diagnosis and use of mental health services
Sixty-six percent of women met criteria for a mood disorder (43% with major depression and 23% with minor depression), 24% for an anxiety disorder (15% with generalized anxiety disorder (GAD) and 9% with panic), and 20% for a probable alcohol disorder. Twenty-one percent reported having a drug problem in the past year. Overall, 73% of the sample had at least one probable Axis I disorder. One-third (33%) reported making at least one mental health visit in the past.
Interest in services
Only one out of the 105 women
Discussion
Rates of psychiatric disorders were very high in this sample of distressed women, with nearly three-quarters having a probable Axis I disorder, suggesting that women reporting distress to their medical providers should be carefully assessed for psychiatric disorders. Similar to the findings of Areán and Miranda [12] with a general medical clinic sample, the majority of women were interested in some form of treatment or psychosocial intervention.
Although interest in services was high, actual
Conclusion
Given the high rates of psychiatric disorders, as well as the substantial interest in a variety of psychosocial services, it is clear that psychologically distressed women’s clinic patients face a number of psychosocial problems for which treatment can be provided. Results from this study highlight the need to ask women seen in public care gynecology clinics about their emotional health, to discuss available treatment options given their limited resources, to address concerns about stigma, to
Acknowledgements
This research was supported by a grant from the Latino Mental Health Research Program, Department of Psychiatry, University of California, San Francisco.
References (28)
- et al.
Do primary care patients accept psychosocial treatments?
Gen Hosp Psychiatry
(1996) - et al.
Treatment-seeking for depression by black and white Americans
Soc Sci Med
(1987) - et al.
Treatment of depression by obstetrician-gynecologistsA survey study
Obstet Gynecol
(1997) - et al.
Specialist/generalist division of responsibility for patients with mental disorders
Arch Gen Psychiatry
(1982) - et al.
Contact with health professionals for the treatment of psychiatric and emotional problems
Med Care
(1985) - et al.
Characteristics of patients with major depression who received care in general medical and specialty mental health settings
Med Care
(1994) - et al.
Lifetime and 12-month prevalence of DSM-III-R Psychiatric Disorders in the United States
Arch Gen Psychiatry
(1994) - et al.
The prevalence and distribution of major depression in a national community sampleThe National Comorbidity Survey
Am J Psychiatry
(1994) - et al.
Unmet mental health needs of women in public care sector gynecology clinics
Am J Obstet Gynecol
(1998) - et al.
Women and outpatient mental health servicesUse by Black, Hispanic, and White women in a national insured population
J Ment Health Admin
(1994)
Comparing use of public and private mental health servicesthe enduring barriers of race and age
Community Ment Health J
Hispanic women and mental healthan overview of contemporary issues in research and practice
Psychol Women Quart
Primary care physicians’ approach to depressive disorders. Effects of physician specialty and practice structure
Arch Fam Med
Patient preferences for treatment of depression
Int J Psychiatry Med
Cited by (139)
Psychological distress and protective factors among Black Americans pre- and post-COVID-19
2023, Encyclopedia of Mental Health, Third Edition: Volume 1-3Ethnic differences in behavioral and physiological indicators of sensitivity to threat
2022, Journal of Anxiety DisordersCitation Excerpt :In addition to variability in demographics and assessment, several other factors may have also contributed to these mixed findings. Factors such as time living in the U.S., social acceptability of self-reporting, acculturation, language, nativity, and socioeconomic status have all been shown to both impact psychopathology and differ between H/L and non-H/L (Alegría et al., 2008, 2014; Alvidrez & Azocar, 1999; Arellano-Morales et al., 2015; Nadeem et al., 2007; Ortega, Rosenheck, Alegría, & Desai, 2000; Potochnick & Perreira, 2010; Van Hook, 1999; Varela et al., 2004). These variables were, unfortunately, not available in the present dataset and thus represent critical areas of future research to better understand ethnic differences in anxiety symptoms and laboratory indicators of threat responding.
Perinatal depression among a global sample of Spanish-speaking women: A sequential-process latent growth-curve analysis
2019, Journal of Affective DisordersTreatment of depression, anxiety, and trauma-related disorders during the perinatal period: A systematic review
2018, Clinical Psychology ReviewTelephone-administered versus live group cognitive behavioral stress management for adults with CFS
2017, Journal of Psychosomatic ResearchWomen and mental health: a gender-sensitive survey on determinants of health and care satisfaction in outpatient psychiatric services
2024, Journal of Sex- and Gender- Specific Medicine