The causes of reduced fertility with cryopreserved semen
Introduction
Cryopreservation of semen has long been seen as a means of benefiting the breeding of animals of agricultural importance, and has been recognised as contributing to the conservation of endangered species and to overcoming aspects of male infertility in humans. Nevertheless, with the possible exception of bull semen, a lower fertility is generally accepted as a consequence of cryopreservation. In this paper I want to offer a perspective on the causes of lower fertility.
Cryopreserved bull semen has been used commercially in dairy cattle for decades and conception results are now comparable or better than with natural mating. However, this is not so for the majority of mammalian species where fertility is clearly reduced by the cryopreservation protocol. Indeed, the losses from cryopreservation are compensated by the insemination of larger numbers of spermatozoa, and this is true for cattle semen as well as other species. The difference between species is explained by the extent of the compensation that can be achieved in cattle, where relatively few spermatozoa are required for good fertility, complete compensation can be achieved by inseminating of the order of 20 million total spermatozoa, still allowing for sufficient dilution of semen to make the process commercially viable. With other species many more spermatozoa are necessary to achieve reasonable fertility, and the losses associated with cryopreservation are such as to preclude the process being commercially viable. As a generalisation, some 40–50% of the population do not survive cryopreservation even with optimised protocols. When comparisons are made on the basis of similar numbers of motile (assumed viable) spermatozoa, results are still generally poorer than with fresh semen, indicating that even the viable subpopulation after cryopreservation is compromised. An approach to overcome the problem in some species has been to utilise surgical insemination permitting the inseminate to be introduced high in the reproductive tract to achieve a more satisfactory fertility, but at the higher cost of surgery.
This phenomenon can be explained by the need to have a sufficient number of fully competent spermatozoa capable of achieving fertilisation over the period when ovulation is likely to occur. The isthmus of the oviduct acts as a functional sperm reservoir providing a source of potentially fertilising spermatozoa over the ovulatory period Hunter, 1984, Hunter and Nichol, 1983. Only a minute proportion of spermatozoa introduced into the lower reaches of the female tract enter the oviducal reservoir, the majority being expelled through the vulva or phagocytosed in the tract. In the ampulla at the time of fertilisation, the sperm:oocyte ratio approaches unity (Hunter, 1996). The numerical and temporal competency of this sperm cohort depends on both the number and quality of spermatozoa introduced into the lower reaches of the tract. Apart from maternally-related aspects, conception at artificial insemination can be seen as a probability event determined by considerations of the inseminate. When the sperm number or quality in the inseminate is reduced fertility declines on an exponential curve (Fig. 1); normally, insemination is performed with sufficient competent spermatozoa to achieve results on the asymptote of this curve. Both the slope of the curve and the asymptote vary with individual sire and can be influenced by cryopreservation procedures (Amann and Hammerstedt, 1993). If the total number of fully functional spermatozoa in a cryopreserved inseminate falls below the number needed to achieve a high probability of fertilisation, then fertility is reduced.
When the inseminate is placed higher in the female tract than is normally the case with artificial insemination, fewer spermatozoa are required to achieve the same probability of fertility since a greater proportion will survive to colonise the oviduct. Thus, with sheep, intrauterine insemination is far more effective than posterior cervical insemination. Maxwell (1986) showed that only 20 million motile cryopreserved ram spermatozoa were required to achieve greater than 50% fertility, whereas it is recognised that cervical insemination requires 10 times that dose. If the insemination was made into the oviduct itself, less than 1 million spermatozoa were needed (Maxwell et al., 1993).
Another observation relating to cryopreserved semen is manifested with boar semen. In the pig, ovulation can occur over an extended period of oestrus such that spermatozoa may be required to survive up to 40 h in the oviduct. Waberski et al (1994) have noted that fertility with cryopreserved semen may be high providing the insemination is made in the period 4 h before ovulation. Outside this period, fertility with cryopreserved spermatozoa declined dramatically, but fresh semen maintained its fertility for a much longer period. Cryopreserved spermatozoa do not survive in the female tract compared with fresh spermatozoa.
In summary, the cryopreservation process results in reduced fertility compared with fresh semen. It has been shown that this arises from a combination of both loss of sperm viability and an impairment of function in the population of survivors. This situation needs to be borne in mind when strategies to improve the results are contemplated. We need to consider not only the cryopreservation protocol to optimise the number of survivors, but also the functional ability of the surviving population.
Section snippets
Increasing the proportion live
The cryopreservation protocol has a number of potentially damaging stresses: firstly, the change in temperature; secondly, the osmotic and toxic stresses presented by exposure to molar concentrations of cryoprotectants; and thirdly, the formation and dissolution of ice in the extracellular environment. We shall discuss these in turn.
Capacitation-like changes
A significant breakthrough in understanding has come with the recognition that cooled and rewarmed spermatozoa behave as if they were capacitated (Watson, 1995). However, we are unsure at present whether spermatozoa manifest the changes of capacitation or simply are enabled to by-pass capacitation and proceed directly to acrosomal exocytosis. We have begun to study this phenomenon and have shown that cooled spermatozoa display chlortetracycline staining and an increase in intracellular free Ca2+
Conclusion
The effects that cryopreservation can induce in spermatozoa, ranging from lethal injury to those which merely impair subsequent function, are numerous. In the last few years, the considerable increase in our understanding both of the cell physiology of spermatozoa and of the stresses of cryopreservation has contributed to a renewed interest in improving the performance of cryopreserved semen.
Today, the biotechnological applications of cryopreservation enjoy an interest which is unprecedented.
References (60)
- et al.
Determination of water permeability coefficient and its activation energy for rabbit spermatozoa
Cryobiology
(1995) - et al.
Cold-induced ultrastructural changes in bull and boar sperm plasma membranes
Cryobiology
(1990) - et al.
Coculture of human sperm with bovine oviduct epithelial cells decreases sperm chromatin structural changes seen during culture in media alone
Fertil. Steril.
(1998) - et al.
In vitro interactions of cryopreserved stallion spermatozoa and oviduct (uterine tube) epithelial cells or their secretory products
Anim. Reprod. Sci.
(1999) - et al.
Comparison of semen quality in young and mature Holstein bulls measured by light microscopy and flow cytometry
J. Dairy Sci.
(1990) - et al.
Mouse spermatozoa in high concentrations of glycerol: chemical toxicity vs. osmotic shock at normal and reduced oxygen concentrations
Cryobiology
(1998) Artificial insemination of ewes with frozen thawed semen at a synchronised oestrus: II. Effect of dose of spermatozoa and site of intrauterine insemination on fertility
Anim. Reprod. Sci.
(1986)- et al.
Water permeability, Lp, of the mouse sperm plasma membrane and its activation energy are strongly dependent on interaction of the plasma membrane with the sperm cytoskeleton
Cryobiology
(1997) - et al.
Frozen storage of ram semen: II. Causes of low fertility after cervical insemination and methods of improvement
Anim. Reprod. Sci.
(1995) - et al.
Comparison of glycerol, other polyols, trehalose, and raffinose to provide a defined cryoprotectant medium for mouse sperm cryopreservation
Cryobiology
(1998)
Effect of time of insemination relative to ovulation on fertility with liquid and frozen boar semen
Theriogenology
Effect of salt concentration and unfrozen water fraction on the viability of slowly frozen ram spermatozoa
Cryobiology
Evidence for increased lipid peroxidative damage and loss of superoxide dismutase activity as a mode of sublethal cryodamage to human sperm during cryopreservation
J. Androl.
Evidence that membrane stress contributes more than lipid peroxidation to sublethal cryodamage in cryopreserved human sperm: glycerol and other polyols as sole cryoprotectant
J. Androl.
In vitro evaluation of sperm quality: an opinion
J. Androl.
Effect of antioxidants tocopherol and ascorbic acids in maintenance of sperm activity during freeze–thaw process
Arch. Androl.
Cryopreservation alters the Ca++ flux of bovine spermatozoa
Can. J. Anim. Sci.
Effect of cryoprotective additives and cryopreservation protocol on sperm membrane lipid peroxidation and recovery of motile human sperm
J. Androl.
In vivo fertilizing capacity of deep-frozen boar semen packaged in plastic bags and maxi-straws
Zentralbl. Veterinarmed., Reihe A
Calculated optimal cooling rates for ram and human sperm cryopreservation fail to conform with empirical results
Biol. Reprod.
The presence of water channel proteins in ram and human spermatozoa
J. Reprod. Fertil.
Reactive oxygen species and sperm physiology
Rev. Reprod.
Subzero water permeability parameters of mouse spermatozoa in the presence of extracellular ice and cryoprotective agents
Biol. Reprod.
Ability of thawed tiger (Panthera tigris) spermatozoa to fertilize conspecific eggs and bind and penetrate domestic cat eggs in vitro
J. Reprod. Fertil.
Cold shock damage is due to lipid phase transitions in cell membranes: a demonstration using sperm as a model
J. Exp. Zool.
Hyperosmotic tolerance of human spermatozoa: separate effects of glycerol, sodium chloride and sucrose on spermolysis
Biol. Reprod.
Prevention of osmotic injury to human spermatozoa during addition and removal of glycerol
Hum. Reprod.
Osmotic properties of boar spermatozoa and their relevance to cryopreservation
J. Reprod. Fertil.
Determination of plasma membrane characteristics of boar spermatozoa and their relevance to cryopreservation
Biol. Reprod.
Influence of cold preservation on the cytoskeleton of cultured pulmonary arterial endothelial cells
Am. J. Respir. Cell Mol. Biol.
Cited by (1134)
Factors affecting the success of laparoscopic artificial insemination in sheep
2024, Animal Reproduction ScienceL-Proline: A Promising Tool for Boosting Cryotolerance and Fertilizing Ability of Cryopreserved Sperm in Animals
2024, Animal Reproduction ScienceCooling of alpaca spermatozoa using an extender with the addition of different percentages of seminal plasma
2024, Animal Reproduction Science