Positive and negative schizotypy in a student sample: neurocognitive and clinical correlates
Introduction
Schizotypal personality disorder (SPD) has been conceptualized as an attenuated form or phenotypic variant of schizophrenia. Diagnostic criteria for SPD include ideas of reference, magical ideation, unusual perceptual experiences, odd thinking and speech, suspiciousness, inappropriate or constricted affect, eccentric behavior, lack of close friends, and excessive social anxiety (American Psychiatric Association, 1994).
Subtle prefrontal deficits are associated with schizotypal personality. Individuals receiving a SPD diagnosis demonstrate a greater degree of impairment on tests assessing frontal executive function including the Wisconsin Card Sorting Test (Diforio et al., 2000, Trestman et al., 1995, Voglmaier et al., 1997), California Verbal Learning Test (Bergman et al., 1998, Voglmaier et al., 1997), and the Trail-Making Test (Trestman et al., 1995). Schizotypic subjects also exhibit performance deficits on visuospatial working memory tasks (Farmer et al., 2000, Park and McTigue, 1997, Roitman et al., 2000). Moreover, schizotypic subjects manifest volumetric abnormalities (i.e. volume reduction) in temporal and prefrontal regions (Dickey et al., 1999, Buchsbaum et al., 1997, Raine et al., 1992a).
University students psychometrically defined as schizotypic or ‘psychosis-prone’ also exhibit performance deficits on tasks assessing frontal executive function including the Wisconsin Card Sorting Test (Lenzenweger and Korfine, 1994, Lyons et al., 1991, Poreh et al., 1995, Suhr, 1997), Trail-Making Test (Poreh et al., 1995), and the Booklet Category Test (Poreh et al., 1995).
Schizotypy is not invariably associated with impaired performance on tasks assessing frontal executive function. Lenzenweger and Gold (2000) found that students psychometrically identified as schizotypic did not demonstrate performance deficits on verbal and auditory working memory tasks in comparison to controls. How can we account for these conflicting results?
One possibility is that students psychometrically defined as schizotypic present with a less severe form of schizotypal personality relative to subjects diagnosed with SPD. However, several studies found that subjects diagnosed with SPD did not demonstrate performance deficits on tests assessing frontal executive functioning (i.e. the WCST) (Raine et al., 1992b, Condray and Steinhauer, 1992).
A second possibility is that neurocognitive deficits are selectively associated with negative, rather than positive, symptoms. A discussion of the two-factor model (or two-syndrome construct) of schizotypy may clarify this issue. A two-factor model of schizotypy is based on Crow's two-syndrome concept of schizophrenia (i.e. Type I — positive symptoms and Type II — negative symptoms) (Crow, 1980, Crow, 1985). Variations in dopaminergic activity are associated with both positive and negative schizotypy (Siever, 1995). Hypodopaminergia in prefrontal cortex is associated with negative symptoms such as affective flattening, avolition and apathy, asociality, and cognitive impairment. Hyperdopaminergia in subcortical mesolimbic structures may generate positive schizotypal symptoms including magical ideation, ideas of reference, and unusual perceptual experiences. Several researchers suggest that positive and negative schizotypy represent distinct factors or dimensions. Siever (1995) noted that these dimensions or factors are independently heritable and speculated that distinct pathophysiologies underlie each dimension.
To determine if distinct neurocognitive profiles are associated with these factors, we classified subjects on the basis of positive and negative schizotypal symptoms and conducted separate analyses of neurocognitive test performance.
Negative schizotypy may be selectively associated with executive dysfunction. Diforio et al. (2000) reported that adolescents with SPD demonstrated performance deficits on the modified WCST. Moreover, impaired performance on the WCST was associated with negative, rather than positive, symptoms. As noted previously, Lenzenweger and Gold (2000) found that students psychometrically identified as schizotypic did not exhibit performance deficits on working memory tasks relative to controls. It is important to note that Lenzenweger and Gold employed the Perceptual Aberration Scale to classify subjects. The Perceptual Aberration Scale taps positive schizotypal symptoms (e.g. perceptual distortions). However, Lyons et al. (1991) recruited schizotypal subjects via newspaper advertisements which highlighted positive symptoms (i.e. advertisements seeking individuals who had experienced paranormal phenomena such as ESP and telepathy) and found that individuals with positive symptom schizotypy demonstrated performance decrements on the WCST relative to control subjects.
The present study uses a student sample to investigate whether subtle prefrontal deficits are selectively associated with negative schizotypal personality features. Following prior work in the neuropsychiatric literature, we predicted that negative schizotypy would be associated with impaired performance on tests assessing frontal executive function.
We also investigated the relationship between positive/negative schizotypy and associated clinical states or personality dimensions including antisocial personality disorder (APD), obsessive–compulsive personality traits, generalized and social anxiety, empathy, and impulsivity. In prior work, we observed an association between schizotypal personality features, obsessive–compulsive personality traits, and excessive social anxiety. Are these clinical states selectively associated with positive or negative schizotypy?
Meehl (1989) suggested that a significant subset of psychopathic subjects are schizotaxic. Siever et al. (1990) found that approximately 20% of SPD patients also met diagnostic criteria for APD. We predicted that individuals psychometrically defined as schizotypic would achieve significantly higher scores on a measure of antisocial personality relative to comparison subjects. Although schizotypy may be associated with antisocial personality, it has not been determined whether antisocial behavior is selectively associated with positive or negative schizotypal personality features and we make no a priori predictions.
In prior unpublished work, we observed an association between measures of impulsivity, empathy, and schizotypal personality. We found that subjects psychometrically defined as schizotypic obtained significantly higher scores on measures of impulsivity and significantly lower scores on measures of empathy relative to matched controls. In the present study, we included self-report measures of impulsivity and empathy.
In prior work, we observed an association between schizotypal personality features and obsessive–compulsive personality traits (OCPTs). Moreover, both OCPTs and schizotypal personality features were associated with performance deficits on tests assessing frontal executive function (Aycicegi et al., 2001, Dinn et al., 2001a, Dinn et al., 2001b). We suggested that the preoccupation with rules and organization, perfectionism, and inflexibility displayed by subjects exhibiting OCPTs may represent behavioral strategies which evolve in response to executive function deficits.
Why would OCPD and schizotypal personality covary? As noted previously, negative symptoms are associated with cognitive deficits (i.e. performance deficits on tests of frontal executive functioning). OCPTs may represent adaptive or compensatory strategies which develop in response to executive function deficits. That is, OC symptoms may represent adaptations to subtle prefrontal deficits associated with negative schizotypy. In the present study, we predict that students obtaining high scores on a measure of negative schizotypal symptoms will also achieve clinically significant scores on a measure of obsessive–compulsive personality.
However, in prior work, we also observed a strong relation between social anxiety and obsessive–compulsive phenomena. Thus, OC symptoms, such as compulsive rituals and checking behaviors, may represent compensatory mechanisms for reducing anxiety. Given that both OCD and SPD are associated with social anxiety, it is important to understand the relation between schizotypy and anxiety states, and separately examine social vs. generalized anxiety. Indeed, excessive social anxiety is a characteristic clinical feature of SPD (American Psychiatric Association, 1994).
Our principal research objectives were:
- 1.
an exploration of the relationship between positive and negative schizotypy, and neuropsychological test performance in a student sample;
- 2.
an investigation of the relation between schizotypy and associated clinical states or personality dimensions including antisocial behavior, obsessive–compulsive phenomena, generalized and social anxiety, empathy, and impulsivity.
Section snippets
Subjects
One hundred and three undergraduate students served as participants for this study. Participants were drawn from introductory psychology courses and received course credit.
The sample comprised 75 female and 28 male students. Female participants had a mean age of 18.6 years (SD=1.0) and had completed 13.4 years of education (SD=0.7). Sixty-seven female subjects were right-handed and eight were left-handed, as determined by self-report. Mean age of male participants was 19.6 years (SD=1.7) and their
Results
Subtyping schizotypy: positive and negative dimensions. Classification of subjects into positive and negative schizotypy groups revealed distinct neurocognitive and clinical profiles. Interestingly, there was no relationship between the positive and negative schizotypy dimensions in the student sample Findings are consistent with the contention that positive and negative schizotypy represent discrete factors (Siever, 1995).
Handedness and schizotypy
In prior work, researchers reported an association between mixed handedness and schizotypal personality features among nonclinical subjects and students psychometrically identified as schizotypic or ‘psychosis-prone’ (Kim et al., 1992, Chapman and Chapman, 1987). We compared the neurocognitive test performance of right- and left-handed students. Ninety-three subjects were right-handed and 10 subjects were left-handed, as determined by self-report. Neurocognitive and clinical profiles were
Gender and schizotypy
Research examining neurocognitive function in schizophrenia reveals significant gender-based differences. Seidman et al. (1997) found that male schizophrenia patients demonstrated performance deficits on measures considered sensitive to orbitofrontal (i.e. an odour discrimination task) and dorsolateral–prefrontal (i.e. the WCST) dysfunction relative to female schizophrenia subjects; however, both male and female schizophrenia patients demonstrated substantial neuropsychological deficits in
Discussion
Classification of subjects into positive and negative schizotypy groups revealed distinct neurocognitive and clinical profiles. There was no relationship between the positive and negative schizotypy dimensions. This finding is consistent with the proposal that positive and negative schizotypy represent discrete dimensions or factors. Of course, multiple comparisons increase the danger of Type I error and our findings should be interpreted with caution. Nevertheless, results form a meaningful
References (53)
Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders
(1994)- Aycicegi, A., Dinn, W.M., Harris, C.L., 2001. Neuropsychological function in obsessive–compulsive personality disorder...
- et al.
Investigations of the functional anatomy of attention using the Stroop test
Neuropsychologia
(1993) - et al.
Verbal learning and memory in schizotypal personality disorder
Schizophr. Bull.
(1998) - et al.
Ventricular volume and asymmetry in schizotypal personality disorder and schizophrenia assessed with magnetic resonance imaging
Schizophr. Res.
(1997) - et al.
Frontal lobe challenge: a comparison of activation procedures during rCBF measurements in normal subjects
Neuropsychiatry Neuropsychol. Behav. Neurol.
(1993) - et al.
Handedness of hypothetically psychosis-prone subjects
J. Abnormal Psychol.
(1987) Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences
(1988)- et al.
PsyScope: an interactive graphic system for designing and controlling experiments in the psychology laboratory using Macintosh computers
Behav. Res. Methods Instrum. Comput.
(1993) - et al.
Schizotypal personality disorder in individuals with and without schizophrenic relatives: similarities and contrasts in neurocognitive and clinical functioning
Schizophr. Res.
(1992)
Molecular pathology of schizophrenia: more than one disease process?
Br. Med. J.
The two-syndrome concept: origins and current status
Schizophr. Bull.
Schizotypal personality disorder and MRI abnormalities of temporal lobe gray matter
Biol. Psychiatry
Executive functions in adolescents with schizotypal personality disorder
Schizophr. Res.
Neurocognitive function in antisocial personality disorder
Psychiatry Res.
Adult attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder: neuropsychological correlates and clinical presentation
Age norms for impulsiveness, venturesomeness, and empathy in adults
Pers. Individ. Differ.
Visual perception and working memory in schizotypal personality disorder
Am. J. Psychiatry
The functional roles of prefrontal cortex in episodic memory. I. Encoding
Brain
The Assessment of Aphasia and Related Disorders
Frontal Lobe Personality Scale
The Analysis of Intelligence
Mixed handedness and features of schizotypal personality in a nonclinical sample
J. Nerv. Mental Dis.
Ventral frontal deficits in psychopathy: neuropsychological test findings
Neuropsychologia
Cited by (118)
Schizotypal traits and neuropsychological performance: The role of processing speed
2020, Schizophrenia ResearchCitation Excerpt :A recent systematic review (Siddi et al., 2017) reports that several neurocognitive impairments were related to schizotypy, in particular cognitive flexibility and verbal and visual working memory. Alternatively, different dimensions of schizotypy may be associated with differential profiles of cognitive impairment (Dinn et al., 2002). Executive function and verbal IQ impairments have been shown to be associated with positive schizotypy (Chang et al., 2011; Noguchi et al., 2008), while attention (Sarkin et al., 1998), working memory (Park and McTigue, 1997), and executive function deficits (Daly et al., 2012) have, for example, been linked to negative schizotypy.
Associations between schizotypal traits and antisocial behaviours in a sub-Saharan sample
2019, Archives of Psychiatric NursingDifferential importance of the basic components of schizotypy: A meta-analysis
2017, Revista Latinoamericana de Psicologia
- 1
Visiting Scholar — Boston University.