Trends in Cognitive Sciences
ReviewMental models and deduction
Section snippets
The theory of mental models
Thinking depends on tacit processes that are guided by constraints: the thinker's goal, if any, and pertinent knowledge and beliefs. The idea that it depends on mental models goes back to the Scottish psychologist, Kenneth Craik, who suggested that perception constructs ‘small-scale models’ of reality that are used to anticipate events and to reason 8. Mental models might originally have evolved as the ultimate output of perceptual processes. They can represent spatial relations 9, events and
One model is better than many
The fewer the number of models needed for an inference, and the simpler they are, the easier the inference should be. It should take less time, and be less prone to error. This prediction is a consequence of the limitations of working memory 17: multiple models can overload its processing capacity and lead to errors in which reasoners fail to consider some models of the premises. Halford and his colleagues have shown that the fewer the entities in a model of a relation, the easier inferences
Truth, meaning, and knowledge
Reasoners focus on what is true and neglect what is false. One consequence is the difficulty of the selection task (Box 3). Another consequence is the occurrence of systematic fallacies (Box 4). And because meaning is central to models, the content of inferences and background knowledge can modulate reasoning. They influence the interpretation of premises 37. The following inference, for example, is valid in form:
Eva is in Rio or she's in Brazil;
She's not in Brazil.
Therefore, she's in Rio.
But
Strategies in reasoning
An important recent discovery is that when individuals carry out a series of inferences, they develop strategies for coping with them. Deduction itself can be a strategy 44, and Western cultures might resort to it more than East Asian cultures 45. However, deduction in turn elicits a variety of strategies 46. An earlier version of the mental-model theory implied that reasoners start reasoning with the most informative premise but this claim is not always true 47. Reasoners’ strategies determine
Conclusions
Deductive reasoning is under intense investigation 59. The field is fast moving and controversial. This article has reviewed just one theory: that reasoning depends on imagining the possibilities compatible with the premises, and drawing conclusions from these mental models. The theory makes five main predictions, which have been corroborated experimentally:
- 1.
One model is better than many. That is, the fewer models needed for an inference, and the simpler they are, the easier the inference.
- 2.
Questions for future research
- •
What underlies the vast differences in reasoning ability from one individual to another? The processing capacity of working memory accounts for some, but not all, of these differences.
- •
Reasoning takes into account relevant general knowledge. What process triggers its recovery from long-term memory?
- •
What is the origin of the different strategies for reasoning, and how do reasoners develop them?
- •
Logic means never having to be sorry about a valid conclusion. In daily life, however, individuals
Acknowledgements
Preparation of this article was supported by a grant from the National Science Foundation (Grant 0076287) to study strategies in reasoning. It was made possible by the community of reasoning researchers. There are too many individuals to name, but the author thanks them all.
References (59)
Who is Rational? Studies of Individual Differences in Reasoning
(1999)Mental animation: Inferring motion from static displays of mechanical systems
J. Exp. Psychol. Learn. Mem. Cognit.
(1992)Working Memory
(1986)Mental models in spatial reasoning
Model construction and elaboration in spatial linear syllogisms
- et al.
Problem representations and illusions in reasoning
- et al.
Rephrasing between disjunctives and conditionals: mental models and the effects of thematic content
Q. J. Exp. Psychol.
(1997) Individual differences and strategy selection in reasoning
Br. J. Psychol.
(1997)Strategies and tactics in reasoning
A Civil Action
The Psychology of Proof
Formal Logic: Its Scope and Limits
Deduction
In favour of a unified model of deductive reasoning
The Nature of Explanation
Array representations for model-based spatial reasoning
Mental models in theory and practice
Imagery, visualization, and thinking
The mental models theory of language comprehension
Mental Models: Towards a Cognitive Science of Language, Inference, and Consciousness
Image and language in human reasoning: a syllogistic illustration
Cognit. Psychol.
Processing capacity defined by relational complexity: implications for comparative, developmental, and cognitive psychology
Brain Behav. Sci.
Human Reasoning: The Psychology of Deduction
Deductive reasoning
Annu. Rev. Psychol.
Mental models and temporal reasoning
Cognition
Reasoning about relations: spatial and nonspatial problems
Think. Reason.
Working memory constraints on linear reasoning with spatial and temporal contents
Q. J. Exp. Psychol.
Cited by (267)
Probabilistic and deductive reasoning in the human brain
2023, NeuroImageAdaptive network modeling of the influence of leadership and communication on learning within an organization
2023, Cognitive Systems ResearchIf and only if people were logical! The effect of pragmatic enrichment on reasoning with abstract and realistic materials
2022, Journal of PragmaticsCitation Excerpt :On the one hand, pragmatic theories of language tacitly assume that the perfection of conditionals happens in the environment of natural language, that is, in everyday meaningful contexts, such as in (6) rather than (5). On the other hand, Bonnefond and Van der Henst (2009) observed that in the domain of the psychology of reasoning the two most popular Models of deduction – Mental Logic (Braine and O'Brien, 1998) and Mental Model Theory (Johnson-Laird and Byrne, 1991; Johnson-Laird, 2001) – treat reasoning as an uniform system, that is, a system that works in a similar way independently of the type of premises given as input. However, as Bonnefond and Van der Henst (2009) point out, fMRI studies have shown that distinct brain networks are involved depending on the content of the premises in a given reasoning task.
Reasoning and decision making
2022, International Encyclopedia of Education: Fourth EditionElection hacking, the rule of sovereignty, and deductive reasoning in customary international law
2023, Leiden Journal of International LawExploring the Future of the Engineer Profession: The Effect of the Entrepreneurial Engineers' Mental Models on Their Opportunity Recognition Capabilities
2024, IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management