Distress tolerance and early smoking lapse☆
Introduction
Cigarette smoking is the leading cause of death and disability in the United States, accounting for over 440,000 deaths in the United States every year (USDHHS, 2004), yet over 45 million adult Americans continue to smoke cigarettes every day (Control, 2004). This strong relationship between smoking and morbidity and mortality, and the clear benefits of successful cessation (USDHHS, 1990), have stimulated a great deal of interest in smoking cessation research. However, despite the desire of 70% of smokers to quit (Control, 1994), the 1 year quit ratio in the general smoking population is under 1% (Fiore, Novotny, Pierce, et al., 1989), and approximately 90–95% of smokers who quit on their own (Cohen et al., 1989) and 70–85% who attend treatment programs relapse within 1 year (Fiore, Bailey, & Cohen, 2000).
The selection hypothesis of smoking prevalence argues that smokers who are unable to quit successfully are likely to possess risk factors or characteristics that make it difficult to quit (Coambs et al., 1989, Hughes, 1995, Irvin & Brandon, 2000, Irvin et al., 2003). Although existing epidemiological evidence is equivocal regarding population level increases in levels of dependence (USDHHS, 2003), significant populations of at-risk, recalcitrant smokers remain (Augustson & Marcus, 2004) and efforts to develop treatments tailored to high-risk populations remain a national priority (USDHHS, 2003). In a review of available clinical trials conducted between 1975 and 1996, Irvin & Brandon (2000) documented a robust decrease in the abstinence rates achieved by intensive cognitive-behavioral smoking cessation interventions. Significant strides in smoking cessation ultimately may be found in the ability to develop specialized treatments that target the particular needs of subgroups of smokers, especially those who are at higher risk for relapse, rather than in expecting any single treatment approach to be a panacea (Brown, 2003a, Lichtenstein & Glasgow, 1992, Niaura & Abrams, 2002, Shiffman, 1993).
In the present article, we will highlight the importance of “early smoking lapse”, based upon the observation that a significant proportion of smokers attempting to quit will relapse within a matter of hours or days of their cessation attempt. In discussing the issues of smoking lapse and relapse, we use the term “lapse” to indicate an instance of smoking (even a puff of a cigarette) and “relapse” to indicate a return to one's baseline level of smoking. We present data suggesting that early smoking lapse following a cessation attempt is a common occurrence, and one that we believe has not received sufficient attention in the smoking treatment literature. Furthermore, we propose that the majority of smokers who lapse within a matter of hours or within days of a cessation attempt may be responding to a combination of physical and psychological discomfort to the nicotine withdrawal syndrome (Hughes, Higgins, & Hatsukami, 1990) that reliably accompanies the initial stages of smoking cessation. These individuals may be characterized by their reduced ability to tolerate the physical discomfort and negative affect associated with nicotine withdrawal and by their lack of persistence in the face of this discomfort.
Baker, Piper, McCarthy, Majeskie, and Fiore (2004) have recently offered a reformulated model of negative reinforcement in addiction, proposing that negative affect is the “motivational core” of the withdrawal syndrome. We agree with this model, and further posit that there are individual differences in how smokers respond to negative affect, and it is these responses in the face of negative affect that determine who lapses and who maintains abstinence. We present data supporting these assumptions and propose that a specialized behavioral treatment for these “early smoking lapsers” is indicated, and would feature components to assist them in learning skills to increase their ability to tolerate discomfort and negative affect and to persist despite experienced discomfort at the task of remaining abstinent from smoking.
Section snippets
Relapse prevention and the significance of early smoking lapse
In light of high smoking relapse rates (Brownell et al., 1986, Garvey et al., 1987, Hunt & Bespalec, 1974), Marlatt and Gordon's (1985) social learning-based (Bandura, 1977), relapse prevention model has stimulated considerable research. The relapse prevention model proposes that an individual's ability to cope successfully with situational factors that may precipitate relapse, and to develop a more balanced lifestyle are the key factors that determine the probability of smoking relapse.
Withdrawal symptom severity
Given the emergence of both physiological and psychological symptoms that occurs within hours of nicotine deprivation (Hughes et al., 1990), severity of nicotine withdrawal might be expected to be the strongest predictor of early lapse and subsequent relapse. Since the 1988 Surgeon General's report affirmed the role of nicotine dependence in the initiation and maintenance of cigarette smoking (USDHHS, 1988), nicotine withdrawal has been an emerging focus of scientific investigation (Hughes, 1992
Distress tolerance and early smoking lapse
Emerging evidence regarding the construct of distress tolerance suggests that it is not just the severity or intensity of nicotine withdrawal, but also how an individual responds to discomfort and distress that predicts early smoking lapses. Early lapsers may be characterized by a tendency towards negative affect during nicotine withdrawal and also an inability to tolerate negative affect. We have previously referred to this combination as a “double whammy” with regard to early lapse in
Development of a novel smoking cessation treatment for early smoking lapsers
Given that the cognitive-affective response to distress may be at the core of early smoking lapse, it is crucial to develop novel treatment strategies for smokers with a history of repeated early lapses that helps smokers tolerate the short-term discomfort associated with acute cessation. In the following section, we outline the development of a “distress tolerance treatment”. We expect that any such treatment would include components of standard smoking cessation treatment, both behavioral and
Summary and conclusions
Recent evidence suggests that a significant percentage of individuals attempting smoking cessation lapse to smoking within a matter of days, and that very few of these individuals are able to recover to achieve abstinence from smoking. Current models of relapse devote insufficient attention to this phenomenon of early lapse. Studies attempting to relate severity of nicotine withdrawal symptoms to short-term smoking cessation outcomes have yielded equivocal results. We believe that how one reacts
References (144)
- et al.
Panic and generalized anxiety disorders. Nature and treatment
Behavior Therapy
(1984) - et al.
Behavioral treatment of panic disorder
Behavior Therapy
(1989) - et al.
Postcessation cigarette use: The process of relapse
Addictive Behaviors
(1990) - et al.
Anxiety sensitivity: Relationship to negative affect smoking and smoking cessation in smokers with past major depressive disorder
Addictive Behaviors
(2001) - et al.
Scheduled reduced smoking: Effects on smoking abstinence and potential mechanisms of action
Addictive Behaviors
(1997) - et al.
An experimental investigation of thought suppression
Behaviour Research and Therapy
(1991) - et al.
A further experimental investigation of thought suppression
Behaviour Research and Therapy
(1993) - et al.
The relations of trait anxiety, anxiety sensitivity, and sensation seeking to adolescents' motivations for alcohol, cigarette, and marijuana use
Addictive Behaviors
(2001) - et al.
Depression and depressive symptoms in smoking cessation
Comprehensive Psychiatry
(1990) - et al.
Instructions to focus upon or distract from internal cues during exposure treatment of agoraphobic avoidance
Behaviour Research and Therapy
(1989)
Predictors of smoking relapse among self-quitters: A report from the normative aging study
Addictive Behaviors
Acceptance theory-based treatment for smoking cessation
Behavior Therapy
Long-term effects of behavioral smoking cessation interventions
Behavior Therapy
Habituation during exposure treatment: Distraction vs. attention-focusing
Behaviour Research and Therapy
Reactions to withdrawal symptoms and success in smoking cessation clinics
Addictive Behaviors
Breath-holding endurance as a predictor of success in smoking cessation
Addictive Behaviors
Predictors and reasons for relapse in smoking cessation with nicotine and placebo patches
Preventive Medicine
Anxiety sensitivity, self-reported motives for alcohol and nicotine use and level of consumption
Journal of Anxiety Disorders
Psychosocial stress and coping in smokers who relapse or quit
Health Psychology
Use of the current population survey to characterize subpopulations of continued smokers: A national perspective on the “hardcore” smoker phenomenon
Nicotine & Tobacco Research
The use of Acceptance and Commitment Therapy to prevent the rehospitalization of psychotic patients: A randomized controlled trial
Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology
Motivational influences on cigarette smoking
Annual Review of Psychology
Addiction motivation reformulated: An affective processing model of negative reinforcement
Psychological Review
Self-efficacy: Toward a unifying theory of behavioral change
Psychological Review
Self-efficacy: The exercise of control
Cognitive therapy of depression
The influence of situation and coping on relapse crisis outcomes after smoking cessation
Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology
The effects of fluoxetine combined with nicotine inhalers in smoking cessation—a randomized trial
Addiction
Mediators of change in emotion-focused and problem-focused worksite stress management interventions
Journal of Occupational Health Psychology
Pretreatment task persistence predicts smoking cessation outcome
Journal of Abnormal Psychology
Comorbidity treatment: Skills training for coping with depression and negative moods
Intensive behavioral treatment
Behavioral treatment of cigarette dependence
Cognitive-behavioral treatment for depression in smoking cessation
Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology
Distress tolerance and duration of past smoking cessation attempts
Journal of Abnormal Psychology
Understanding and preventing relapse
American Psychologist
The effects of smoking schedules on cessation outcome: Can we improve on common methods of gradual and abrupt nicotine withdrawal?
Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology
The future of tobacco use and smoking research
Debunking myths about self-quitting
American Psychologist
Cigarette smoking among adults—United States, 1993
Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report
Cigarette Smoking among Adults—United States 2002
Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report
Reversal theory constructs and cigarette availability predict lapse early in smoking cessation
Research in Nursing and Health
A motivational model of alcohol use
Journal of Abnormal Psychology
Urges to smoke during the first month of abstinence: Relationship to relapse and predictors
Psychopharmacology
Learned industriousness
Psychological Review
Cited by (253)
Smoking status affects cognitive, emotional and neural-connectivity response to distress-inducing auditory feedback
2023, Drug and Alcohol DependenceClinically Significant Distress and Physical Problems Detected on a Distress Thermometer are Associated With Survival Among Lung Cancer Patients
2023, Journal of the Academy of Consultation-Liaison PsychiatryDistress tolerance and stress-induced emotion regulation behavior
2022, Journal of Research in PersonalityEmotion dysregulation in children with autism: A multimethod investigation of the role of child and parent factors
2022, Research in Autism Spectrum DisordersAssociation of depression symptom level with smoking urges, cigarette withdrawal, and smoking reinstatement: A preliminary laboratory study
2022, Drug and Alcohol DependenceCitation Excerpt :Thus, utilizing experimental laboratory methodologies, such as those that allow comparisons of cigarette abstinence with non-abstinence, may be warranted. Additionally, as most smoking lapses tend to occur during early abstinence (Kenford et al., 1994; Shiffman et al., 1997) and specifically within the first few hours of abstinence from smoking (Brown et al., 2005; Hébert et al., 2021), controlled laboratory procedures allow for the investigation of smoking urges, withdrawal, and smoking reinstatement during early acute abstinence. Furthermore, as individuals with elevated depression symptoms may be at risk for poor cessation outcomes, it is important to understand how the relationship of abstinence and these smoking-related variables differ by depression symptom level to help identify abstinence barriers for individuals with elevated depression symptoms.
Examining the effects of stress and psychological distress on smoking abstinence in cancer patients
2021, Preventive Medicine Reports
- ☆
This paper was partially supported by a National Cancer Institute research grant awarded to Dr. Brown (CA88297) and by National Institute on Drug Abuse research grants to Drs. Brown (DA017332), Lejuez (RO1 DA15375) and Zvolensky (DA16307-01 and DA016227).