Compression testing of very soft biological tissues using semi-confined configuration—A word of caution

doi:10.1016/j.jbiomech.2007.06.025

Journal of Biomechanics

Volume 41, Issue 1, 2008, Pages 235-238

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbiomech.2007.06.025 Get rights and content

Abstract

We analyse semi-confined (i.e. using no-slip boundary conditions) compression experiment of very soft tissue sample using finite element method. We show that the assumption that the planes perpendicular to the direction of the applied force remain plane during the experiments is not satisfied for compression levels lower than previously stated in Miller [2005. Method for testing very soft biological tissues in compression. Journal of Biomechanics 38, 153–158]. Therefore, we recommend that the parameters for constitutive models of very soft tissues be determined by fitting a solution of the finite element models of the experimental set-up to the measurements obtained using semi-confined compression experiments.

Introduction

The mechanical properties of very soft biological tissues—such as the brain, liver and kidney—are of interest to several fields, including computer-integrated surgery and biomechanical analysis of injury due to impacts. Determination of the mechanical properties of these soft tissues remains an experimental and analytical challenge.

In our previous publications, we suggested a way to reliably test very soft tissues in compression (Miller, 2005) and extension (Miller, 2001) using a semi-confined configuration. This method relies on attaching cylindrical samples of low aspect ratio to stress–strain machine platens using surgical glue, which allows using no-slip boundary conditions in the analysis of measurement results. The semi-confined test configuration has been used by a number of researchers, e.g. Cheng and Bilston (2007), Cheng and Chen (2003), Miller and Chinzei (2002), and Snedeker et al. (2005).

The applicability of the analytical relationships between stress and strain derived in our previous papers depends on the major assumption that the planes within the sample perpendicular to the direction of the applied force remain plane during the test is satisfied. In this paper, we analyse in detail the semi-confined compression experiment using the finite element method in an attempt to evaluate the validity of this assumption.

Section snippets

Finite element analysis of compression experiment

The semi-confined compression experiment set-up proposed by Miller (2005) is essentially the same as those used previously (Estes and McElhaney, 1970; Miller and Chinzei, 1997) but replaces a no-friction boundary condition at the tissue–platen interfaces, that is difficult to implement in practice, by a no-slip boundary condition (see Fig. 1).

We constructed a finite element model of the semi-confined compression experiment using the ANSYS software (ANSYS, Inc., Canonsburg, PA, USA). Cylindrical

Results

When simulating the compression experiment, we found that the cylindrical surface of the material sample came in contact with the platens at much lower compressions than initially thought. This material behaviour is best observed in Fig. 2.

Clearly, the increase of the contact surface demonstrates that the assumption stating that the planes perpendicular to the direction of the applied force remain plane is violated. Consequently, part of the measured reaction force is carried through the

Discussion and conclusions

Assumption 3 of Miller (2005) states: ‘the planes perpendicular to the direction of the applied force remain plane’. This assumption is invalid when the cylindrical surface of the material sample comes in contact with the compressing platen (formation of the expansion ring). Thus the model proposed by Miller (2005) for analysis of semi-confined compression experiments of very soft tissues is limited to analysis before formation of the expansion ring. We find that this occurs at a compression of

Conflict of interest

We have no conflicts of interest to report. All other than the employment sources of financial support (The Australian Research Council and The National Institute of Health) are disclosed in Acknowledgements.

Acknowledgements

The financial support of the Australian Research Council (Grants no. DP0770275 and DP0664534) and the National Institute of Health (Grant no. R03 CA126466-01A1) is gratefully acknowledged.

References (16)

M. Cheng et al.
Experimental investigation of the stress–stretch behavior of EPDM rubber with loading rate effects
International Journal of Solids and Structures
(2003)
S. Cheng et al.
Unconfined compression of white matter
Journal of Biomechanics
(2007)
J. Ivarsson et al.
Strain relief from the cerebral ventricles during head impact: experimental studies on natural protection of the brain
Journal of Biomechanics
(2000)
S.S. Margulies et al.
Physical model simulations of brain injury in the primate
Journal of Biomechanics
(1990)
K. Miller
How to test very soft biological tissues in extension
Journal of Biomechanics
(2001)
K. Miller
Method for testing very soft biological tissues in compression
Journal of Biomechanics
(2005)
K. Miller et al.
Constitutive modeling of brain tissue: experiment and theory
Journal of Biomechanics
(1997)
K. Miller et al.
Mechanical properties of brain tissue in tension
Journal of Biomechanics
(2002)

There are more references available in the full text version of this article.

Cited by (31)

Embryonic aortic arch material properties obtained by optical coherence tomography-guided micropipette aspiration
2023, Journal of Biomechanics
Citation Excerpt :
One valuable motivation of the present study is to develop a micro-scale measurement protocol that will fully-resolve the mechanical properties of the great vessels and link this information to the published study on elastin and collagen content at these stages (Celik, Goktas et al. 2020). There are several established experimental techniques for macroscopic mechanical characterization, including multi-axial extension/compression of the soft vascular tissue with arbitrary internal compositions and structural fabric (Holzapfel 2006, Morriss, Wittek et al. 2008) and other methods (Siddiqui, Dogru et al. 2022). Since the measurements in these experiments are relatively noise-free, the accuracy usually depends on the experimental design particularly on the use of clamps or tethers, as well as initial loading and residual stresses.
It is challenging to determine the in vivo material properties of a very soft, mesoscale arterial vesselsof size ∼ 80 to 120 μm diameter. This information is essential to understand the early embryonic cardiovascular development featuring rapidly evolving dynamic microstructure. Previous research efforts to describe the properties of the embryonic great vessels are very limited. Our objective is to measure the local material properties of pharyngeal aortic arch tissue of the chick-embryo during the early Hamburger-Hamilton (HH) stages, HH18 and HH24. Integrating the micropipette aspiration technique with optical coherence tomography (OCT) imaging, a clear vision of the aspirated arch geometry is achieved for an inner pipette radius of Rp = 25 μm. The aspiration of this region is performed through a calibrated negatively pressurized micro-pipette. A computational finite element model is developed to model the nonlinear behaviour of the arch structure by considering the geometry-dependent constraints. Numerical estimations of the nonlinear material parameters for aortic arch samples are presented. The exponential material nonlinearity parameter ( $a$ ) of aortic arch tissue increases statistically significantly from $a$ = 0.068 ± 0.013 at HH18 to $a$ = 0.260 ± 0.014 at HH24 (p = 0.0286). As such, the aspirated tissue length decreases from 53 μm at HH18 to 34 μm at HH24. The calculated NeoHookean shear modulus increases from 51 Pa at HH18 to 93 Pa at HH24 which indicates a statistically significant stiffness increase. These changes are due to the dynamic changes of collagen and elastin content in the media layer of the vessel during development.
Simple and robust element-free Galerkin method with almost interpolating shape functions for finite deformation elasticity
2021, Applied Mathematical Modelling
In this paper, we present a meshless method belonging to the family of element-free Galerkin (EFG) methods. The presented meshless method allows accurate enforcement of essential boundary conditions. The method uses total Lagrangian formulation with explicit time integration to facilitate code simplicity and robust computations in applications that involve large deformations and non-linear materials. We use a regularized weight function, which closely approximates the Kronecker delta, to generate interpolating shape functions. The imposition of the prescribed displacements on the boundary becomes as straightforward as in the finite element method (FEM). The effectiveness and accuracy of the proposed method is demonstrated using 3D numerical examples that include cylinder indentation by 70% of its initial height, and indentation of the brain.
Mechanics of human vocal folds layers during finite strains in tension, compression and shear
2020, Journal of Biomechanics
During phonation, human vocal fold tissues are subjected to combined tension, compression and shear loading modes from small to large finite strains. Their mechanical behaviour is however still not well understood. Herein, we complete the existing mechanical database of these soft tissues, by characterising, for the first time, the cyclic and finite strains behaviour of the lamina propria and vocalis layers under these loading modes. To minimise the inter or intra-individual variability, particular attention was paid to subject each tissue sample successively to the three loadings. A non-linear mechanical behaviour is observed for all loading modes: a J-shape strain stiffening in longitudinal tension and transverse compression, albeit far less pronounced in shear, stress accommodation and stress hysteresis whatever the loading mode. In addition, recorded stress levels during longitudinal tension are much higher for the lamina propria than for the vocalis. Conversely, the responses of the lamina propria and the vocalis in transverse compression as well as transverse and longitudinal shears are of the same orders of magnitude. We also highlight the strain rate sensitivity of the tissues, as well as their anisotropic properties.
Sample, testing and analysis variables affecting liver mechanical properties: A review
2016, Acta Biomaterialia
Given the critical role of liver mechanics in regulating cell response and directing the development of tissue fibrosis, accurately characterising its mechanical behaviour is of relevance for both diagnostic purposes as well as for tissue engineering and for the development of in-vitro models. Determining and quantifying the mechanical behaviour of soft biological tissues is, however, highly challenging due to their intrinsic labile nature. Indeed, a unique set of values of liver mechanical properties is still lacking to date; testing conditions can significantly affect sample status and hence the measured behaviour and reported results are strongly dependent on the adopted testing method and configuration as well as sample type and status. This review aims at summarising the bulk mechanical properties of liver described in the literature, discussing the possible sources of variation and their implications on the reported results. We distinguish between the intrinsic mechanical behaviour of hepatic tissue, which depends on sample variables, and the measured mechanical properties which also depend on the testing and analysis methods. Finally, the review provides guidelines on tissue preparation and testing conditions for generating reproducible data which can be meaningfully compared across laboratories.
Soft tissue mechanics is widely investigated, but poorly understood. This review identifies and discusses sample and testing variables which can influence the mechanical behaviour of hepatic tissue and consequently the measured mechanical properties. To encourage the biomaterial community towards more standardized testing of soft tissues and enable comparisons between data from different laboratories, we have established new testing methods and experimental recommendations for sample preparation and testing. The review could be of wide interest to scientists involved in biomaterials research because it addresses and proposes guidelines for several issues related to the mechanical testing of soft tissues whose implications have not been considered together before.
On the mechanical characterization and modeling of polymer gel brain substitute under dynamic rotational loading
2016, Journal of the Mechanical Behavior of Biomedical Materials
Citation Excerpt :
No available Mooney–Rivlin model and no Ogden with six parameters were found by the authors. Nevertheless, the Neo-Hookean parameters found in this study was agree with the works from (Moerman et al., 2009; Morriss et al., 2008). In such complex models of deep indentation needed hyperelastic laws involving one or more parameters provided a response.
The use of highly sensitive soft materials has become increasingly apparent in the last few years in numerous industrial fields, due to their viscous and damping nature. Unfortunately these materials remain difficult to characterize using conventional techniques, mainly because of the very low internal forces supported by these materials especially under high strain-rates of deformation. The aim of this work is to investigate the dynamic response of a polymer gel brain analog material under specific rotational-impact experiments. The selected polymer gel commercially known as Sylgard 527 has been studied using a specific procedure for its experimental characterization and numerical modeling.
At first an indentation experiment was conducted at several loading rates to study the strain rate sensitivity of the Sylgard 527 gel. During the unloading several relaxation tests were performed after indentation, to assess the viscous behavior of the material. A specific numerical procedure based on moving least square approximation and response surface method was then performed to determine adequate robust material parameters of the Sylgard 527 gel. A sensitivity analysis was assessed to confirm the robustness of the obtained material parameters.
For the validation of the obtained material model, a second experiment was conducted using a dynamic rotational loading apparatus. It consists of a metallic cylindrical cup filled with the polymer gel and subjected to an eccentric transient rotational impact. Complete kinematics of the cup and the large strains induced in the Sylgard 527 gel, have been recorded at several patterns by means of optical measurement. The whole apparatus was modeled by the Finite Element Method using explicit dynamic time integration available within Ls-dyna^® software. Comparison between the physical and the numerical models of the Sylgard 527 gel behavior under rotational choc shows excellent agreements.
On a staggered iFEM approach to account for friction in compression testing of soft materials
2013, Journal of the Mechanical Behavior of Biomedical Materials
An inverse finite element method (iFEM) to estimate material parameters from compression tests of soft materials is presented, where alginate hydrogel was used as a phantom material. The method applies if the boundary conditions at the loaded surfaces are not ideal, i.e. neither free of friction nor fully constrained, as it may be the case in most realistic testing set-ups. Assuming a linear friction law, the friction coefficient $μ$ was considered unknown and estimated in a first step by minimising the difference between the contours of the sample, obtained by optical measurements, and the simulated shape. Force–displacement data were used in a second step to determine the parameters of the constitutive law. Staggering these two steps, both friction and material parameters were identified by optimisation. Skipping the first step and predefining $μ$ instead, a unique parameter set could only be clearly identified if the deviations of the contours were considered in addition to the deviations in the force–displacement data. Finally, forward FEM calculations with differently shaped specimens were used to verify the goodness of the obtained parameter sets.

View all citing articles on Scopus

View full text

Short communicationCompression testing of very soft biological tissues using semi-confined configuration—A word of caution

Abstract

Introduction

Section snippets

Finite element analysis of compression experiment

Results

Discussion and conclusions

Conflict of interest

Acknowledgements

International Journal of Solids and Structures

Journal of Biomechanics

Journal of Biomechanics

Journal of Biomechanics

Journal of Biomechanics

Journal of Biomechanics

Journal of Biomechanics

Journal of Biomechanics

Short communication
Compression testing of very soft biological tissues using semi-confined configuration—A word of caution