Original communicationPhysical methods of torture and their sequelae: a Sri Lankan perspective
Introduction
Torture is not a wanton display of anger. It is executed systematically to cause maximum suffering to the victim without causing death or severe disability. To achieve this objective the torturers have invented a wide range of methods. Some of these methods like ‘falaka’ and ‘submarino’ are well known. Though their popularity may vary from place to place they are being used for torture by different groups despite their many other differences. However, there are other methods improvised ad hoc by the torturers using things available at the vicinity. These methods can vary not only from country to country but also from one region to the other within the same country.
The forensic physician, who is requested to examine a torture victim, needs to understand the methods of torture used in a particular country or region to evaluate their physical sequelae with confidence. There is no doubt that fearlessness, independence and honesty are good qualities of a doctor engaged in medico-legal work. But they are not enough to fight against this awesome social evil. They should be knowledgeable and skilful in dealing with torture as their presentation can be very complex.1 Systematic and scientific documentation of torture is a step towards improving their knowledge. In addition, such documentation of torture makes it possible for the human rights activists to take the perpetrators of torture to justice both at the national and international level.2
Section snippets
Methodology
This is a retrospective study done on the case records of 100 torture victims who were examined in the Office of the Judicial Medical Officer in Colombo during the period between 1998 and 2001. The definition of torture adopted by United Nations Convention against Torture was used in this study. All the victims had been arrested mainly from the northern and eastern provinces of the country on charges of terrorism under the Prevention of Terrorism (Temporary Provisions) Act No. 48 of 1979 (PTA)
Sex and age distribution (Fig. 1)
Eighty-nine percent were male and 11% were female. Forty percent of the victims were between 21 to 25 years. Eighty-four percent were between 16 and 35 years of age. The youngest person in this group was just 16 years of age whereas the oldest person was 61 years. Only 9% were above 40 years.
Interval between the torture and the examination (Fig. 2)
Since no victim could remember the exact date or dates of torture, interval between the torture and examination could not be calculated accurately. However, all the victims claimed that they were tortured
Discussion
This study was done on the case records of the victims of torture referred to the Office of the Judicial Medical Officer, Colombo for medico-legal examination. The singular objective of the judges, who had referred them, was to know whether the ‘detainees’ were tortured as claimed. It was very clear from the outset that the treatment of the victim was not an issue. The victim also had one expectation, which was to obtain a report from the doctor confirming their claim. We, as forensic medical
Acknowledgements
I thank Dr. L.B.L. de Alwis, Consultant Judicial Medical Officer, Colombo, Sri Lanka and Dr. M.P.A.B. Abeysinghe, Consultant Judicial Medical Officer, Negambo, Sri Lanka for their advice and support during data collection for this study.
References (6)
Exposing the horror of torture
The Lancet
(2003)- et al.
Torture and its sequel - a comparison between victims from six countries
Forensic Sci Int
(2003) The physical sequelae of torture
Cited by (17)
Suspension torture and its physical sequelae
2021, Journal of Forensic and Legal MedicineCitation Excerpt :Inverted suspension with the ankles fixated upwards and the body extended downwards is known as Reverse Butchery suspension (See Fig. 1, illustration D). Inverted suspension can also occur by the toes, regularly the first toe.12 One of the more complex examples of suspension methods that are mentioned in the literature is the Parrot Perch.
Torture-induced hand electrical injury: A case report
2021, Journal of Forensic and Legal MedicineCitation Excerpt :Nowadays, torture is still practiced on detainees in certain countries with various purposes such as obtaining information, punishment, intimidation, or for any reason based on discrimination of any kind.1 The typical objective of torture is inflicting maximum pain without causing serious injury or death.2 Clinical examination of the victims usually reveals few signs suggestive to the torture allegations.2–4
Intentional burn injury: Assessment of allegations of self-infliction
2017, Journal of Forensic and Legal MedicineCitation Excerpt :Subsequent research on 90 torture victims in Sri Lanka in 2007 found that 8% reported having been burnt with heated metal objects (not including cigarettes).4 In the same year Perera reported an incidence of 11% for such burns in a study based on records of 100 torture victims from 1998-2001.5 Multiple reliable sources reporting widespread evidence of torture in Sri Lanka subsequent to the end of hostilities in 2009 are cited in regularly updated UK Home Office country of origin information and guidance documents that are routinely relied upon by asylum decision-makers in the UK and in other jurisdictions.6
Asylum seekers alleging torture in their countries: Evaluation of a French center
2017, Journal of Forensic and Legal MedicineDiagnosis of torture after 32 years: Assessment of three alleged torture victims during the 1980 military coup in Turkey
2014, Forensic Science InternationalImplementation of Istanbul Protocol for effective documentation of torture - Review of Sri Lankan perspectives
2011, Journal of Forensic and Legal MedicineCitation Excerpt :However Sri Lanka has not yet shown significant positive signs of attempting to combat torture through existing legislative and administrative and policing mechanisms. A recent retrospective study performed on torture methods adopted in Sri Lanka has revealed application of 68 different methods of torture.1 In another recent study the researchers were able to detect 37 physical and psychological methods practised on torture victims.2