Critical reviewFluency disorders in genetic syndromes
Introduction
It is well known that certain genetic syndromes are associated with communication disorders. For example, Adler (1976) suggested a strong link between specific syndromes and resulting speech and language disorders. Yet, the study of communication disorders in genetic syndromes has only gained significant interest in the past few years, most likely with the expansion of knowledge in the human genome project. Only recently have attempts been made to compile the available sparse information in order to gain a more comprehensive picture of the occurrence of communication disorders in genetic syndromes.
The most extensive overview to date is that of Shprintzen (1997) who compiled data on the major features, primary etiology, speech production, resonance, voice, language and hearing of 334 syndromes. Remarkably, the occurrence of stuttering or other fluency disorders received little mention on this list. The only two exceptions include Down syndrome and fragile X syndrome. In Down syndrome it said that “dysfluency” and “rapid bursts of speech” may occur (Shprintzen, 1997, p. 226). Information in fragile X syndrome is slightly more extensive: “dysfluency with classical stuttering and in some cases, ‘cluttering’; in more severe cases, nonsensical short bursts of perseverative or absent speech” (Shprintzen, 1997, p. 264). With these shortfalls in mind, the purpose of the present paper is to give a more detailed review of the occurrence and nature of fluency disorders in a number of genetic syndromes. In addition to Down syndrome and fragile X syndrome, Prader-Willi syndrome, Tourette syndrome, neurofibromatosis type I, and Turner syndrome will be discussed. It should be recognized that these syndromes vary with respect to their underlying cause and to the presence of any associated problems (in particular mental retardation). They were included in the present review because, as far as we could ascertain, they are the only ones for which some information on speech nonfluencies is available. This was established through searches of several major search engines, and follow-up review of the articles. In some cases, the terms “stuttering” and/or “disfluency” appeared in the citation or abstract, however, specific definitions or descriptions of these terms were not provided. For ease of understanding, the term “developmental stuttering” will be used throughout this review. This term will be used to refer to the most typical types of stuttering seen in children and adults, that is, the term will not be used to describe stuttering associated with acquired neurological disorders (Helm-Estabrooks, 1999), acquired psychogenic stuttering (Baumgartner, 1999), or cluttering (St. Louis, 1992). For clarification, acquired neurogenic stuttering refers to transient stuttering that begins with the onset of a specific, identifiable neurological event (ASHA, 1999); acquired psychogenic stuttering refers to stuttering that is clearly related to psychopathology (ASHA, 1999); and cluttering refers to a fluency disorder that is not stuttering and is characterized by rapid and/or irregular speech rate, along with associated disturbances in language and/or attention. In addition to this terminology, the following terms will be used throughout this manuscript for ease in understanding and interpretation.
Disfluency: The non-stuttered breakdowns in fluent speech. The term disfluency will be used to identify the types on fluency breakdowns that are not considered to be stuttering and include interjections of sounds, repetitions of phrases, revisions, and incomplete phrases (Johnson, 1959; Silverman & Williams, 1967), as well as other forms of non-stuttered fluency breakdowns, such as circumlocutions, additions, and verbal mazes (Paul, Tetnowski, & Reuler, 2007).
Dysfluency: The stuttered breakdowns in fluent speech. These are the most common breakdowns in fluency that are perceived by listeners to be stuttering (Yairi, 1996) and those breakdowns in fluency that are most likely classified as stuttering according to experts in the field of stuttering (Ham, 1989). This term is synonymous with stuttering (ASHA, 1999), and following the lead of Yairi, will be referred to as stuttering-like disfluencies (SLD) throughout the remainder of this manuscript. The terms SLD and stuttering will be used to identify the part-word repetitions, single syllable word repetitions, prolongations, and blocks that are most consistently identified as stuttering.
Nonfluency: In many research papers, breakdowns in fluency are not clearly delineated as being either “disfluency” or “SLD”. Some of these same papers do not clearly describe whether they are referring to disfluency or SLD. The term “fluency” refers to the continuity of spoken language units (ASHA, 1999), and is the opposing term of “nonfluency”. Throughout this review, nonfluency will be the catch-all term used to refer to all breakdowns in fluency. This term will include non-determinate types of fluency breakdown that can include both categories (i.e., disfluencies and SLD).
Section snippets
Down syndrome
Down syndrome is a well-known condition resulting from trisomy 21. It is characterized by some typical physical characteristics such as a short stature, a flat occiput, small and slanting palpebral fissures, epicanthic folds (skin folds of the upper eyelid covering the inner corner of the eye), a depressed nasal bridge, a small nose, and an overlarge tongue relative to the size of the mouth. The syndrome is also associated with behavioral characteristics including the presence of speech and
Fragile X syndrome
With an estimated prevalence of 1/4000 in males and 1/8000 in females, fragile X syndrome is the second most frequent cause of mental retardation of genetic origin after Down syndrome (Goldson & Hagerman, 1992; Turner, Webb, Wake, & Robinson, 1996). The condition finds its origin in a defect on the long arm of the X-chromosome and has as typical physical features a prominent mandible, a long and narrow face, large low-set ears, hyperextensible finger joints, and macro-orchidism (testicular
Prader-Willi syndrome
Prader-Willi syndrome is a multiple anomaly disorder with an incidence estimated at 1/5000 to 1/25000 (Akefeldt, Gillberg, & Larson, 1991; Burd, Vesely, Matsolf, & Kerbeshian, 1990; Greenswag & Alexander, 1995). The syndrome results from the loss of imprinted genomic material within the paternal 15q11.2-13 locus. Deletion of the same part of the chromosome in the mother leads to Angelman syndrome. Typical clinical features of Prader-Willi syndrome include hypotonia at birth, hypogonadism
Tourette syndrome
A syndrome that is often discussed in relation to stuttering is Tourette syndrome. Tourette syndrome, named after the French physician, Georges Gilles de la Tourette, is characterized by the presence of multiple motor tics and one or more vocal tics that cause marked distress or significant impairment in social, occupational, or other important areas of functioning. It has its onset before the age of 18 and is not due to the direct physiological effects of a substance or a general medical
Neurofibromatosis type I
Neurofibromatosis type I, formerly called Von Recklinghausen disease, is a progressive autosomal dominant disorder with an estimated prevalence of two to three cases per 10,000 population (Friedman, 1999). The condition is characterized by the presence of neurofibromas and abnormal cutaneous pigmentation including café-au-lait spots and axilliary freckling. The responsible gene is situated on the long arm of chromosome 17 (Barker et al., 1987).
A review of the literature (Bekaert, Van Borsel, &
Turner syndrome
Turner syndrome is a syndrome that occurs only in females with an estimated incidence of 1/2500 (Hook & Warburton, 1983). It is known to result from a missing X-chromosome with its main features being a short stature, ovarian dysgenesis (defective development of the ovaries), neck webbing, congenital peripheral lymphedema (swelling of the lymph passages), coarction of the aorta, cubitus valgus (deformity of the elbow in which the elbow deviates from the midline of the bone when extended),
Discussion and conclusion
It is clear that certain syndromes may be associated with a fluency disorder but also that knowledge is presently still very limited. This review exemplifies this shortcoming. For a number of syndromes, it is clear that they are closely linked with a fluency disorder and research on the prevalence and nature of the speech fluency disorder has already been conducted. This appears to be the case for Down syndrome, fragile X syndrome, Prader-Willi syndrome and Tourette syndrome. For other
John Van Borsel is a professor of logopedics and neurolinguistics at the Ghent University and an associate editor of Journal of Fluency Disorders. His research interests include fluency disorders, articulation and phonological disorders, genetic syndromes, and the voice in transsexuals. He has published numerous articles in international journals.
References (102)
- et al.
Features resembling Tourette's syndrome in developmental stutterers
Brain and Language
(1998) - et al.
Speech fluency in Prader-Willi syndrome
Journal of Fluency Disorders
(2000) - et al.
Speech disfluencies in individuals with Tourette syndrome
Journal of Psychosomatic Research
(2005) - et al.
Prader-Willi syndrome
Journal of Pediatrics
(1972) What are we measuring?
Journal of Fluency Disorders
(1989)Phenomenology and classification of tics
Neurological Clinics of North America
(1997)- et al.
The nature of speech and language impairment in adults with neurofibromatosis 1
Journal of Neurolinguistics
(1999) - et al.
Familial relationship between Gilles de la Tourette syndrome, attention deficit disorder, learning disability, speech disorders and stuttering
Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry
(1993) - et al.
Communication problems in Turner syndrome: A sample survey
Journal of Communication Disorders
(1999) - et al.
Repetitions in final position in a nine year old boy with focal brain damage
Journal of Fluency Disorders
(1996)
Dysfluency and phonic tics in Tourette syndrome: A case report
Journal of Communication Disorders
Fragile X speech phonology in Finnish
Brain & Language
The influence of genetic syndromes upon oral communication skills
Journal of Speech and Hearing Disorders
Voice, speech and language characteristics of children with Prader-Willi syndrome
Journal of Intellectual Disability Research
Prader-Willi syndrome in a Swedish rural country; epidemiological aspects
Developmental Medicine and Child Neurology
Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders
Terminology pertaining to fluency and fluency disorders: Guidelines
Asha
Clinical voice disorders. An interdisciplinary approach
Gene for von Recklinghausen neurofibromatosis is in the pericentromeric region of chromosome 17
Science
Acquired psychogenic stuttering
Spraak en taal bij neurofibromatose Type 1
Tijdschrift voor Logopedie en Audiologie
Conversational characteristics of children with fragile X syndrome: Repetitive speech
American Journal on Mental Retardation
A handbook on stuttering
Stuttering in the retarded
Mental Retardation Bulletin
Speech disorders: Aphasia apraxia and agnosia
Speech and language characteristics of children with Prader-Willi syndrome
The loci of stutterings in the speech sequence
Journal of Speech Disorders
Behavior Assessment Battery: A multidimensional evidence-based approach to diagnostic and therapeutic decision making for children who stutter
Prevalence study of Prader-Willi syndrome in North Dakota
American Journal of Medical Genetics
Some findings in speech and voice therapy among mentally deficient children
Folia Phoniatrica
A Brazilian cohort of patients with Tourette's syndrome
Journal of Neurology
Comorbid behavioral disorders
Aphasiology and other aspects of language
Speech dysfluency and manual specialization in Down's syndrome
Journal of Mental Deficiency Research
Speech and language issues
Phonological abilities of a preschool child with Prader-Willi syndrome
Journal of Speech and Hearing Disorders
Management of speech and language impairment in a case of Prader-Willi syndrome
Language, Speech, and Hearing Services in Schools
The development of language abilities in Mongols: A correlational study
Journal of Mental deficiency Research
Conversational skills of individuals with fragile-X syndrome: A comparison with autism and Down syndrome
Developmental Medicine and Child Neurology
Epidemiology of neurofibromatosis type I
American Journal of Medical Genetics
The fragile X syndrome
Developmental Medicine and Child Neurology
Syndromes of the head and neck
Management of Prader-Willi syndrome
Neuropsychological dysfunction among affected heterozygous fragile X females
American Journal of Medical Genetics
Fragile X syndrome, monograph
Current Problems in Pediatrics
The fragile X syndrome
Fragile X syndrome: Diagnosis treatment and research
Speech disturbances (cluttering) in mildly impaired males with the Martin-Bell/Fragile X syndrome
American Journal of Medical Genetics
Stuttering associated with acquired neurological disorders
Cited by (60)
Developmental stuttering, physical concomitants associated with stuttering, and Tourette syndrome: A scoping review
2023, Journal of Fluency DisordersThe effect of manual movements on stuttering in individuals with down syndrome
2023, Journal of Fluency DisordersInfluence of gestures on the intelligibility and comprehensibility of utterances with stuttering events in individuals with Down syndrome
2022, Journal of Communication DisordersAn experiment on measuring awareness of stuttering in individuals with Down syndrome
2021, Journal of Fluency DisordersCitation Excerpt :Stuttering is a fluency and communication disorder characterized by involuntary repetitions, prolongations, and blocks of sounds or syllables in ongoing speech (Scott, 2017). Approximately thirty percent of individuals with DS stutter (Eggers & Van Eerdenbrugh, 2018; Kent & Vorperian, 2013; Van Borsel & Tetnowski, 2007), which is considerably higher than the estimated 5 % prevalence rate in the population of persons with an intellectual disability or than the estimated 1 % of the general population (Van Borsel & Tetnowski, 2007; Yairi & Ambrose, 2013). Despite the high prevalence of stuttering in individuals with DS, little is known about these individuals’ awareness of stuttering.
Speech disfluencies in children with Down Syndrome
2018, Journal of Communication DisordersSpecific subtype of fluency disorder affecting French speaking children: A phonological analysis
2016, Journal of Fluency DisordersCitation Excerpt :According to the authors, there exists insufficient evidence to provide solid theories about whether the pathogenisis of final word repetitions is developmental or neurogenic. Disfluencies concerning the final part of words have also been reported in cases of genetic syndromes, such as developed by Van Borsel and Tetnowski (2007) who reported in their review of literature cases of patients with the X fragile syndrome, Prader-Willi and Gilles de la Tourette. Lebrun and Van Borsel (1990) also described a case of final word repetitions in a 17-year-old girl with Down’s syndrome.
John Van Borsel is a professor of logopedics and neurolinguistics at the Ghent University and an associate editor of Journal of Fluency Disorders. His research interests include fluency disorders, articulation and phonological disorders, genetic syndromes, and the voice in transsexuals. He has published numerous articles in international journals.
John A. Tetnowski is the Ben Blanco endowed professor in communicative disorders at the University of Louisiana at Lafayette. He is a board recognized fluency specialist and mentor, and is the 2006–2007 NSA “SLP of the Year”. He has published and presented extensively on stuttering and qualitative methods. He has treated PWS for over 20 years.