Trends in Genetics
Update
Research FocusPositive and negative selection on the mitochondrial genome
Research Focus
Introduction
The neutral theory of molecular evolution predicts that the amount of genetic variation within a population will be positively correlated with the size of the population 1, 2. Large populations experience relatively less genetic drift and, as a result, retain more segregating alleles than small populations where new mutations are easily lost. In a recent study, Bazin et al.[3] compiled published animal mitochondrial (mt)DNA sequences and observed that the average amount of mitochondrial nucleotide polymorphism was remarkably invariant across taxa spanning a wide range of inferred population sizes. By contrast, a smaller set of nuclear-encoded sequences showed the expected positive relationship between average genetic diversity and population size. Bazin et al.[3] concluded that mtDNA might, in fact, be a poor indicator of population size, and suggested that frequent episodes of natural selection are the cause of this discrepancy [3]. Specifically, they invoke an evolutionary process that has been termed ‘genetic draft’ [4] (Box 1 and Glossary) to explain their observation. According to the draft hypothesis, the reduction in variation caused by recurrent selective sweeps balances the expected greater levels of neutral diversity in larger populations, making variation independent of population size [4]. The conclusions of Bazin et al.[3] challenge the utility of mtDNA variation as a reliable indicator of population size and, consequently, this suggestion has generated some debate in the literature 5, 6, 7, 8.
Section snippets
Positive selection on mitochondrial genes?
If genetic draft is responsible for the observed independence of mtDNA polymorphism from population size, this should leave the signature of positive selection in the mtDNA of species with larger population sizes. Bazin et al.[3] tested this prediction by considering the ratio of nonsynonymous to synonymous fixations between species (dN/dS) in whole mitochondrial genomes of taxa with small (vertebrates) versus large (invertebrates) population sizes. Although all dN/dS ratios were well below
Caught in the draft: slightly deleterious mutations and selective sweeps
There are several ways in which evolution without frequent positive selection on mtDNA variants could nonetheless produce a constant level of mitochondrial polymorphism. First, recent theoretical work has demonstrated that certain population models can generate a decoupling of variation and population size in the absence of selection [17]. It remains to be seen whether such processes are good models for mtDNA evolution. Second, the excess amino acid divergence between species could be the
Concluding remarks
There is clearly a great deal to be learned about how selection shapes mitochondrial genome evolution. Mitochondrially encoded proteins evolve much more slowly than predicted by the high mutation rate in the mitochondrial genome [22], so purifying selection on nonsynonymous mutations is clearly an important component of mitochondrial evolution. However, Bazin et al.[3] force a careful evaluation of the role of positive selection. If selective sweeps are so common in mtDNA, why does it
Acknowledgements
This work was supported by NIH grants GM072399 to C.D.M., GM076812 to K.L.M., and GM067862 to D.M.R. and NSF grant DEB 0108500 to D.M.R. We thank four anonymous reviewers whose comments greatly improved this manuscript.
Glossary
- dN/dS
- the ratio of nonsynonymous (amino acid-altering) changes per nonsynonymous site to synonymous changes per synonymous site. This ratio is used to infer the type of evolutionary pressure acting on a protein: when dN/dS > 1 positive Darwinian selection is inferred; when dN/dS = 1.0, strict neutrality is inferred; and when dN/dS < 1, purifying selection is inferred.
- Genetic draft
- the reduction in nucleotide diversity in a genomic region linked to a locus that experiences recurrent fixation of
References (32)
The role of population size in molecular evolution
Theor. Popul. Biol.
(1999)Evolutionary genomics in Metazoa: the mitochondrial DNA as a model system
Gene
(1999)- et al.
Approximating selective sweeps
Theor. Popul. Biol.
(2004) - et al.
A coalescent model for the effect of advantageous mutations on the genealogy of a population
Stoch. Proc. Appl.
(2005) The effect of strongly selected substitutions on neutral polymorphism: analytical results based on diffusion theory
Theor. Popul. Biol.
(1992)- et al.
Protein polymorphism as a phase of molecular evolution
Nature
(1971) Population size does not influence mitochondrial genetic diversity in animals
Science
(2006)Genetic drift in an infinite population. The pseudohitchhiking model
Genetics
(2000)Mitochondrial DNA and population size
Science
(2006)Mitochondrial DNA and population size - Response
Science
(2006)