Abstract
Objectives: This study examined the association between participation in Medicaid managed care and up-to-date coverage for childhood immunizations and screenings among private practice physicians serving New York City's poorest neighborhoods. Method: A random sample of 2174 children 3–35 months of age was drawn from 60 physician practices in 1995, and a cross-sectional analysis was used to compare up-to-date status for immunizations, and lead and anemia screening tests, for children cared for by managed care and nonmanaged care physicians. In 1996, an independent sample of 2380 children from the same practices was used to compare up-to-date status for individual children enrolled in Medicaid managed care and children predominantly enrolled in traditional fee-for-service Medicaid. Information from physician interviews augmented chart review data. Chi-square analysis and logistic regression were used. Results: Physicians who participate in Medicaid managed care and those who do not had equal up-to-date coverage for immunizations (41.0 vs. 36.9%, p = .527), and lead (46.8 vs. 38.7%, p = .199) and anemia screening (63.2 vs. 56.5%, p = .272). Measures of the process of care were also similar for the two groups of physicians. Children themselves enrolled in Medicaid managed care appeared significantly more likely to be up-to-date than their nonmanaged care counterparts for immunizations (OR = 1.53, p = .027) and anemia screening (OR = 2.95, p = .000). Conclusions: Participation in managed care does not seem to change physicians' overall preventive care practice behavior. Available data did not reveal major differences in demographics or health status between individual children enrolled in managed care and those not enrolled. That children enrolled in managed care were better immunized and screened than those in fee-for-service Medicaid suggests that physicians receiving compensation under two payment systems may treat children differently depending on each child's mode of reimbursement.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
REFERENCES
Health Care Financing Administration. Medicaid managed care enrollment report. Washington, HCFA, Office of Managed Care, 30 June 1996.
Sparer, MS, Medicaid managed care and the health reform debate: Lessons from New York and California. J Health Politics, Policy Law, 21:433–460, 1996 Fall.
Illinois may scrap 1115 Medicaid waiver. State Health Watch: The Newsletter on State Health Care Reform 1997;4(10) October.
United Hospital Fund. Medicaid Managed Care Currents 1996;1(3):1.
United Hospital Fund. Medicaid Managed Care Currents 1997;2(1):1.
Liu J, Rosenbaum S. Medicaid and childhood immunizations: A national study. Washington, DC: Children's Defense Fund, 1992.
Physician's Payment Review Commission. Annual report, 1994. Washington, DC: Physician Payment Review Commission, 1994.
New York State Department of Health, Office of Managed Care. 1995 Quality assurance reporting requirements: A report on managed care performance. Albany: New York State Department of Health, December 1997.
Kennedy C, Fairbrother G. Medicaid managed care study: Summary of findings from Plan medical director interviews. Unpublished report submitted to the New York City Department of Health, July 1997.
National Committee on Quality Assurance. Report Card Pilot Project. Washington, DC: NCQA; 1995.
New York State Department of Health and New York State Department of Social Services. Managed care quality assurance reporting requirements. Unpublished, 1993.
Fairbrother G, Hanson KL, Butts G. Medicaid Managed Care in New York: Problems and promise for childhood Immunizations. J Public Health Manage, Pract 1996;2:60–66.
Wood D, et al. Access to Infant Immunizations for poor, inner-city families: What is the impact of managed care? J Health Care Poor Underserved 1994;5:113–23.
Shah-Canning D, Alpert JJ, Bauchner H. Care-seeking patterns of inner-city families using an emergency room: A three decade comparison. Med Care 1996;34:1171–1179.
Kelley MA, Perloff JD, Morris NM, Liu W. Primary care arrangements and access to care among African-American women in three Chicago communities. Women Health 1992;18:91–106.
Fairbrother G, DuMont KA, Friedman S, Lobach KS. New York City physicians serving high volumes of Medicaid children: Who are they and how do they practice? Inquiry 1995;32:345–352.
Brelloch C, Carter AB, Caress B, Goldman A. Building primary health care services in New York City's low-income communities. New York: Community Service Society of New York, 1990.
Morehead, MA. Bronx Professional Standards Review Organization: Experiences with ambulatory care review. Bull NY Acad Med. 1982;58:127–132.
Lee JL, Morehead MA. Utilization and cost of ambulatory care services of Medicaid Recipients, Bronx. Am J Public Health 1984;74:1367–1370.
Stamm JB, Schimel D, Postel AH, Bellin LE. Typical diagnostic and therapeutic errors in Manhattan Shared Health Facilities. Bull NY Acad Med 1983;59:393–400.
Fairbrother G, Friedman S, DuMont K, Lobach KS. Markers for primary care: Missed opportunities to immunize and screen for lead and tuberculosis by private physicians serving large numbers of inner-city Medicaid-eligible children. Pediatrics 1997;6:785–790.
United Hospital Fund. New York City community health atlas. New York: United Hospital Fund, 1994.
Fairbrother G, Hanson K, Friedman S, Butts GC. Impact of bonuses, enhanced fees, and feedback on childhood immunization coverage rates. Am J Public Health.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Guidelines for Assessing Vaccination Levels of the 2-Year-Old Population in a Clinic Setting Atlanta, GA: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Public Health Service. October, 1992.
Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices. General recommendations on Immunization. MMWR 1994;43(1):1–38.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Preventing lead poisoning in young children. Atlanta, GA: CDC, 1991.
Committee on Nutrition, American Academy of Pediatrics. Pediatric nutrition handbook, 3rd ed. Elk Grove Village, IL: AAP, 1993.
Lee, Forthofer, Lorimor, Analyzing complex survey data. Newbury Park, CA: Sage University Press, 1989.
Shah, Barnwell, Hunt, LaVange, SUDAAN user's manual: Professional software for survey data analysis for multi-stage sample designs. Research Triangle Park, NC: Research Triangle Institute, 1992.
New York State Department of Health. Women, infants and children (WIC) program manual. Albany: New York State Department of Health, June 1996.
Perloff JD, Kletke PR, Neckerman KM. Physicians' Decision to limit Medicaid participation: Determinants and policy implications. J Health Politics, Policy Law 1987;12:221–235.
Public Health Service. Healthy People 2000—National health promotion and disease prevention objectives. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Health and Social Services, Public Health Service, 1991.
Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report. July 25, 1997.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Hanson, K.L., Fairbrother, G., Kory, P. et al. The Transition from Medicaid Fee-for-Service to Managed Care Among Private Practitioners in New York City: Effect on Immunization and Screening Rates. Matern Child Health J 2, 5–14 (1998). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1021837407789
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1021837407789