Clinical ArticlesThe case for a universal, valid, reliable 5-tier triage acuity scale for US emergency departments*,**
Section snippets
Triage systems
A triage system is the basic framework with which patients are sorted, using an acuity rating scale. In the most simplistic form, a “traffic director” greets and directs the patient to the correct treatment area based on an initial impression. This system was used by 4.8% of responding emergency departments in the ENA 1998 database5; however, most emergency departments use 1 of 3 other triage systems: spot check, comprehensive, or 2-tier.
Acuity scales
The ideal—every patient being immediately seen in the treatment area—is just not feasible. Therefore, the focus usually becomes the ordering of patients by acuity ratings within the system.
Five-tier acuity ratings
An awareness of the added precision and consistency of a 5-tier acuity rating system is growing. A 1996 ENA study found that 10% of the responding emergency departments already used some form of a 5-level acuity rating,11 although considerable individual and regional variations exist.
Internationally, national standardized 5-level systems with proven reliability and reproducibility are being instituted. To aid comparison, descriptions are made by 5 numerical levels, with 1 being the highest
Conclusion
“The music has changed, so must the dance” is an African proverb. So it is with the US ED triage acuity systems. Studies show that the widely used 3-tier system is ineffective in meeting the needs of today's burgeoning ED patient population. The solution seems to lie not in attempting to improve individuals' performance within the same system but in embracing an improved process.
The call for change is clear, even though the system that is best suited for use in the United States is not as
Acknowledgements
I acknowledge with gratitude the input of Debbie Travers, RN, MSN; the late Richard C. Wuerz, MD; David Eitel, MD, MBA; Nicki Gilboy, RN, MS; Janet Marsden, MSc, BSC, RGN, OND, MiMgt; Lisa Hadfield-Law, RNG, A/E Cert.; and Brian Dolan, BSC (HONS), RMN RGN, CHSM.
References (31)
- et al.
Re-evaluating triage in the new millennium: a comprehensive look at the need for standardization and quality
J Emerg Nurs
(1999) Triage: how long does it take? How long should it take?
J Emerg Nurs
(1999)A triage vital sign policy for a children's hospital emergency department
J Emerg Nurs
(1998)Manager's forum
J Emerg Nurs
(2001)- et al.
Reliability of the Canadian ED Triage & Acuity Scale: inter-rater agreement
Ann Emerg Med
(1999) - et al.
Inconsistency of emergency department triage
Ann Emerg Med
(1998) Critical condition
Time
(2000 Jan 31)National ambulatory medical care survey: 1997 emergency department summary (Vital and Health Statistic)
(1999)Quick reference to triage
(1999)National emergency department benchmark and staffing database guide
(1999)
Standards of emergency nursing practice
Emergency medicine in Australia
Ann Emerg Med
Triage: meeting the challenge
National emergency department benchmark and staffing database guide
Triage: limitations in predicting need for emergent care and hospital admission
Ann Emerg Med
Cited by (47)
Competencies Emergency and Mental Health Nurses Need in Triage in Acute Mental Health Care: A Narrative Review
2024, Journal of Emergency NursingFactors influencing door-to-triage- and triage-to-patient administration-time
2022, Australasian Emergency CareEmergency nurses’ knowledge and experience with the triage process in Hunan Province, China
2017, International Emergency NursingCitation Excerpt :The Australasian Triage Scale was first developed and implemented in Australia in 1993 and was substantially revised in 2000. It is also a 5-point triage scale, with patients allocated to different categories based on their need for time-critical intervention, the potential threat to their life from their presenting problem and the need to relieve suffering [2,3,6]. In mainland China, most EDs do not have a dedicated emergency triage system in place and there is a shortage of appropriately trained triage nurses [1]; however, large urban hospitals are increasingly adopting triage scales [7].
Identifying complexity in infectious diseases inpatient settings: An observation study
2017, Journal of Biomedical InformaticsEmergency medical services triage using the emergency severity index: Is it reliable and valid?
2013, Journal of Emergency NursingRank aggregation methods comparison: A case for triage prioritization
2013, Expert Systems with Applications
- *
For reprints, write: Polly Gerber Zimmermann, RN, MS, MBA, CEN, 4200 N. Francisco, Chicago, IL 60618; E-mail: [email protected]
- **
J Emerg Nurs 2001;27:246-54.