Chest
Volume 118, Issue 5, November 2000, Pages 1480-1485
Journal home page for Chest

Opinions/Hypotheses
Augmentation Therapy Reduces Frequency of Lung Infections in Antitrypsin Deficiency: A New Hypothesis With Supporting Data

https://doi.org/10.1378/chest.118.5.1480Get rights and content

Study objectives

To propose an hypothesis thatantiprotease augmentation therapy reduces the incidence of lunginfections in α1-antitrypsin (AAT)-deficient patients,and to present supporting data.

Design

Theproposed concept is based on a survey taken via the Internet ofpatients receiving augmentation therapy for 1 to 10 years compared tosimilar patients not receiving such therapy.

Setting

A questionnaire was submitted to patients with a ZZ phenotype for AATdeficiency to determine whether those receiving antitrypsinaugmentation therapy were aware of any personal benefit, and whetherthe therapy had an effect on the frequency of lung infections.

Patients

Ninety-six adult patients receiving humanα1-proteinase inhibitor (α1-PI) responded,as did 47 similar patients not receiving augmentation therapy.

Results

Seventy-four of 89 patients who had receivedα1-PI infusions for > 1 year believed that they haddefinitely benefited from such therapy. Fifty-six of the 74 patientsclaiming a benefit attributed this to a reduction in the number of lunginfections since starting therapy with α1-PI infusions.Before starting α1-PI, the majority of patients had threeto five infections per year, dropping to zero to one infection per yearduring α1-PI therapy (p < 0.001).

Conclusions

Replacement therapy for AATdeficiency-associated emphysema appears to be associated with a markedreduction in the frequency and severity of lung infections. Thisassociation must be evaluated further in future, more rigid,prospective studies of AAT augmentation therapy. Findings support thehypothesis that antiprotease therapy with α1-PI reducesthe incidence of lung infections in addition to slowing thedeterioration of lung function and causing a reduction inmortality.

Section snippets

Patients

Patients were recruited through announcements on theα1 Internet List. The appropriatequestionnaires were made available to all participants on the list andwere then returned by the responders by private e-mail to one personwho sorted the replies and forwarded them to Dr. Lieberman forevaluation.

Questionnaires

The questionnaires prepared for ZZ patients who wereparticipants on the α1 Internet List includedinformation on sex, age, and age when patients had received a diagnosisof AAT, as well as on smoking

Results

Questionnaires were filled out and submitted by 96 adult patientswith homozygous ZZ AAT deficiency (this includes one patient of SZphenotype) who were receiving α1-PI replacementtherapy (group I). This group included 50 men and 46 women. The agerange for men was 36 to 67 years (median age, 50 years), and the agerange for women was 33 to 72 years (median age, 53 years). The agerange at which a diagnosis of AAT deficiency was made for men was 28 to66 years (median, 40 years), and the age range

Discussion

The results of studies conducted by means of a questionnairesurvey directed to patients with AAT deficiency, who had ZZ phenotypeand were participating in the α1 Internet List,suggest that augmentation therapy with α1-PI isassociated with a marked reduction in the frequency of lung infectionsin the majority of patients. Most patients reported a frequency ofthree to five infections per year before startingα1-PI therapy, which dropped to zero to oneinfection per year while receiving α1-PI. Intwo

Questionnaire Used for Group I Patients Receivingα1-PI Augmentation Therapy

Questions for group II patients are the same as those for groupI, except for questions dealing with α1-PI. Thequestions that were eliminated were Nos. 4, 5, 6, 11a, 11b, 11c, 12a,12b, and 12c. Questions added were Nos. 11 and 12.

  • 1.

    Sex

  • 2.

    Age

  • 3.

    Age when diagnosed AAT deficient

  • 4.

    Date started on α1-PI

  • 5.

    How often do you receive α1-PIinfusion?

  • 6.

    How do you receive the infusion (hospital, doctor's office,home, other)?

  • 7.

    In addition to emphysema, do you have asthma?

  • 8.

    Do you have allergies?

  • 9.

    Do you have chronic bronchitis or

ACKNOWLEDGMENT

The author acknowledges the most valuableassistance of Mr. Carsten Larsen of Copenhagen, Denmark, and Mr. ClaudeBaril of Montreal, Canada in conducting the questionnaire survey. Thereport is dedicated to the memory of Mr. Claude Baril who was theoriginator of the α1 Internet List, which providesmuch-needed support to those born with AAT deficiency with theirpredisposition to lung and liver disease. His death on January 4, 1999,followed soon after a lung transplant operation.

References (15)

There are more references available in the full text version of this article.

Cited by (0)

View full text